Page 2 of 3

Posted: 2007-06-17 11:35
by Bob_Marley
No.

Posted: 2007-06-17 11:44
by TheParadoX
I would love to See the VSS in PR ! It was in Desert Combat, and I miss it (it was a bit overpowered though). But silent weapons are missing in PR !

Posted: 2007-06-17 12:09
by Bob_Marley
Look. The VSS is execptionally rare outside of Russian Special Forces.

You want to give the Malitia a suppressed rifle, model an AKMN with PSO-1 and PBS-1. It would be much more realistic than the ultra rare VSS (along with the VSS's ultra rare ammo.)

Posted: 2007-06-17 13:00
by ZaZZo
Listen to the Bob, he is always right in a weapons talk.

Posted: 2007-06-17 13:48
by BetterDeadThanRed
EASTER EGG!!!

Posted: 2007-06-17 14:58
by ArmedDrunk&Angry
Bob has spoken so the weapon clearly does not belong in the game.
But on a technical note, if it is firing a 9mm subsonic round wouldn't if have less penetrating power on body armor ?
Larger bullet and lower speed generally mean less penetration AFAIK.

Posted: 2007-06-17 15:14
by Bob_Marley
ArmedDrunk&Angry wrote:Bob has spoken so the weapon clearly does not belong in the game.
But on a technical note, if it is firing a 9mm subsonic round wouldn't if have less penetrating power on body armor ?
Larger bullet and lower speed generally mean less penetration AFAIK.
It depends on the round its firing. The standard SP-5 ball round is nothing to shout about, but loaded with the SP-6, which is an armour piercing round with a hardened steel penetrator core, it can defeat most forms of body armour, though I would question its performance against the ceramic plate inserts on osprey or interceptor bodyarmour. Bassically it can defeat the "soft" parts of the body armour out to around 400m, with the SP-6 round. However, it is less mechanically accurate with the SP-6 than the SP-5, supposedly.

Posted: 2007-06-17 15:18
by billdan
if the vss was implemented it would be with the militia and only 1 pick up kit on the map. its recoil would be 5,000times greater than the ridiculous desert combat vss laser gun (not bashing DC, in fact no game i have ever played and will ever play will EVER replace this game in my heart. i feel nostalgic just typing about it)
but of course the Enfield would be much more realistic for insurgents-why do they get the mosin nagant in .6?

Posted: 2007-06-17 15:44
by Eddie Baker
ArmedDrunk&Angry wrote:Bob has spoken so the weapon clearly does not belong in the game.
But on a technical note, if it is firing a 9mm subsonic round wouldn't if have less penetrating power on body armor ?
Larger bullet and lower speed generally mean less penetration AFAIK.
Well, remember force = mass x velocity. You can get the same numerical force with a heavy projectile at low velocity as you can with a light projectile and a high velocity. Though the projectile may be subsonic, maybe half as fast as the 7.62 x 39mm projectile, it also weighs about twice as much as the 7.62 x 39mm projectile. Also take into account the density of the projectile used; as Bob said, the SP-6 AP round has a steel penetrator running through its length and is exposed at the end. It may not travel as far as a supersonic projectile, but it is going to pack a serious punch, especially at the close ranges the VSS was designed for.

Posted: 2007-06-17 16:14
by Eddie Baker
HellDuke wrote:Holy cow.. Did you study balistics? :smile:
No, just grade school physics; I couldn't remember all the names of the laws if I tried, but the formulas they really drill into your head. :)

Posted: 2007-06-17 16:17
by ArmedDrunk&Angry
OK
Thank You

Posted: 2007-06-17 16:20
by [LTC] Gunther.S [4SFG]
What could be done is it could be a 50/50 deal. 50% chance you get the VSS when you spawn in. And 50% chance you get the ak47 when you spawn in. As a specific class of course.

And who said this weapon will make things unbalanced? Im sure other people said that about the AH-1Z.

There is always a way of balancing things.

Posted: 2007-06-17 18:28
by Bob_Marley
HellDuke wrote:Where are you from? I'm in 11th (gonna be in 12th this year) grade and i am planing on taking the physics exam. :smile:

Now that i think of it in this game basic laws are all that you need. No wind here, nor the density of air and other factors :smile: Ppl soon forget how to apply the laws in everyday life etc, but we are being taught so that nothing would take that out of our brains.

Ok, back to the topic. The thing about overpowering is that as every weapon this one can be deadly in the right hands. The problem here is that there are quite a lot more right hands with this thingy than your stadart issue m24 sniper rifle.
I'd rekon that the VSS would take rather more adjustment to get used to than the other sniper rifles, it has a very parabolic trajectory (due to using a heavy, slow round) which would make it hard to simply pick up and use by anyone.

It would have much more drop than the other rifles, which means that the zero would be very harsh. Say its zeroed for 300m (a resonable range considering its 400m maximum effective range), to hit a target at 200m they would have to aim a good deal below it and to score hits at longer ranges they would have to aim a fair bit above the central cross hair. Nothing that you cant get used to, but it'd be much harder to pick up and use than say an M14 or SVD.

Also, as IIRC BF2 models bullet drop on a liner rather than exponential scale, it might not be possible to properly represent this ingame, though it would be better if we could get one of the DEVs to comment on how BF2 modles bullet drop.

On the other hand, it would have the advantages of full auto capability for close defence and being supressed.

Edit:
Image

Thats the sort of thing I'm thinking of for a possible Malitia suppressed scoped rifle.

Posted: 2007-06-17 21:49
by ArmedDrunk&Angry
What game is that from ?

Posted: 2007-06-17 22:13
by Bob_Marley
Brigade E5: New Jagged Union

Posted: 2007-06-17 23:22
by hoc_xfirestormx
haha why are you guys even posting in this forum? just ignore the troll. where are the mods? i know if i say the R word theyll come running. i hope i dont have to resort to that.

and by R word i mean... uh... razzamataz.