Page 2 of 16

Re: [Map] Siege at Ochamachira

Posted: 2008-09-29 06:32
by Scot
3 ftw, militia in urban area = win.

Re: [Map] Siege at Ochamachira

Posted: 2008-09-29 06:52
by Mj Pain
Ghost1800 wrote:My vote goes for 3. I'd love to see some urban fights with the militia equipment.
What he said.

Re: [Map] Siege at Ochamachira

Posted: 2008-09-29 08:40
by Drude
ahhhhh... I luv militia maps.

Re: [Map] Siege at Ochamachira

Posted: 2008-09-29 09:53
by Reddish Red
Candidate 3, Militia in Urban as others have said.

Re: [Map] Siege at Ochamachira

Posted: 2008-09-29 10:12
by HunterMed
yay... glad u decided for map 2. Finally a map where militia (a non coaltion force) ATTACKS!

Re: [Map] Siege at Ochamachira

Posted: 2008-09-29 10:15
by LtSoucy
2 or 3. Bith would be epic. 4 is too much like muttrah, would seem like a copy. ;)

Re: [Map] Siege at Ochamachira

Posted: 2008-09-29 10:25
by THE.FIST
3 my chice

Re: [Map] Siege at Ochamachira

Posted: 2008-09-29 10:44
by marcoelnk
welcome back irontaxi :)
anything you will do will turn out fine :)

Re: [Map] Siege at Ochamachira

Posted: 2008-09-29 11:49
by Tirak
Candidate 3, interesting harbor design plus FIBUA, pure win.

Re: [Map] Siege at Ochamachira

Posted: 2008-09-29 12:14
by Scandicci
'[R-DEV wrote:IronTaxi;812971']SO.... here they are...

I already chose one.. BUT...

which would you choose?


candidate 1?
Image

Candidate 2?
Image

Candidate 3?
Image

Candidate 4?
Image

:)

Image
If you are after a coastal map with forests and a port to defend then image 2 or image 4 are the best and I would opt for image 2.

Re: [Map] Siege at Ochamachira

Posted: 2008-09-29 13:25
by Spaz
1 or 4

Re: [Map] Siege at Ochamachira

Posted: 2008-09-29 13:31
by =Romagnolo=
3 has too much industryal area and 4 has almost nothing.


I stay between 1 and 2. A littler more to 1 than 2.

Re: [Map] Siege at Ochamachira

Posted: 2008-09-29 13:37
by cyberzomby
Uphill fights can go unbalanced very quick! I think Ill go with candidat 4

Re: [Map] Siege at Ochamachira

Posted: 2008-09-29 14:05
by MadTommy
All sounds good.. i hope you get to make the Hill map idea one day.. i really like the sound of that!

Re: [Map] Siege at Ochamachira

Posted: 2008-09-29 14:29
by Waaah_Wah
3 looks too similar with Muttrah. I like 4 ;)

Re: [Map] Siege at Ochamachira

Posted: 2008-09-29 15:43
by Angry_M0b=US=
1 looks really nice like the layout, and a good mix of city to open land and water, would make for some intresting tacitcs and firefights.
2 looks good, apart from a lot of open dockard, not many buildings
I think that 3 has too much city in it, nice to have some city and open land
the layout of the land and city in 4 is nice, I like the industrial look, but its too small for my liking.

so all in all 1 gets my vote.

Re: [Map] Siege at Ochamachira

Posted: 2008-09-29 15:48
by CarnivorousVulgaris
I would go for no. 2. I like this harbour lay-out the best!