Project Reality Forums

I liked Helmand. Insurgents, fields and Brits in one package. The map was still new to me when I played it, then it was removed.

Steel Thunder, lots of tank lots of fun

Helmand was at times awful (mainly with more than 32 players) but when it was 32 players or less, it was beautiful and felt so real at times.
I don't want the 0.6 map, but hopefully Sangin will bring back the things that were so good about it

Going down the list:

Steel Thunder:
Great map but lagged like hell. If they could get the lag down, then it would be a fantastic map for mech warfare.

Desert Storm:
Client-side effects kinda sucked, but a cool map in terms of chokepoints.

Inishail/Phoenix:
Frag fests TBH. Didnt like em. Felt a lot like vanilla and no room for proper infantry tactics.

Helmand-
Bad balancing, good map. Need some more balancing tho.

Compton-
I loved it when it wasnt crashing/lagging. Would love to see it again.

Greasy-
Should be brought back IMO. Perfect mech inf/armor map.

Muttrah- Too old for the current style. Personally didnt like it all that much back then but it had its moments.

Mao-
Frag fest TBH. Was charge charge charge on full auto with a supply train of medics reviving and everyone else fragging. Was too much like karkand.

Goods Station-
Nice 10v10 or so map, anything bigger got fragfest.


Bi Ming was nice, I like the day version much more than night tho.

CP Abadan was awesome back in its prime. I could see a scenario mode working out on it, nothing vehicular tho.

Steel Thunder.
Helmand Province.

and Operation Phoenix, but only if you find a way to make the grass not disappear on the farm.
I liked the Operation Phoenix but it was annoying to get shot when hiding in this thick, two meters high grass

why is PR getting sucked into a "bigger is better" mentality?

Occasionally, I'll jump on a 64 player server, and with the new spawn rules, I'll feel competely alone for what seems like forever. And before anyone starts, yes.. I stick with my squad and follow orders, it's just some maps are HUGE and firefights are few and far between.

I really liked how Phoenix was set up, seemed more realistic in a way. Moving from the hills to a somewhat dense urban area.. it was a lot of fun, and I saw plenty of infantry tactics on that map.

I'm definitely in the "kill kashan" (or I call it de_dust) crowd. it's just gigantic, nothing to see... really quite boring. I can get behind trying to capture a flag in an urban area, but capturing bland, grey bunkers in the middle of a desert, or bland, grey blown-out buildings in the middle of a desert... boring. bigger is not always better, but that's just MHO.

'[T wrote:waylay00;714960']I don't get the attraction to Helmand. It's too small for PR, and not really different than Strike at Karkand in terms of gameplay.

wtf not really differnt from karkand?

Helmand played very well and required teamwork it was nothing like karkand in anyway what so ever.

why do you feel it was like that?

I suspect he means grenade spam.

I voted Op.Greasy Mullet,because...That map is just...amazing..has a feel like no other..

I really wish I could've voted for more than one...

Maps I want back:
Op. Greasy Mullet
Helmand Province

Plz to has Steel Thunder with no tanx plz?

Rofl cheos on


I want to see Basrah 0.5 come back with Brits in it in AAS mode.

Bi Ming Night - Great map, while I love the day version. Night time was so much better. Somthing about getting a 6 man squad in right past the enemy was great.

Mao - My best .5 map, as long as the undergrowth is fixed (bushes didpiper the farther you get away) Im in for a remake. Great map and a whole lot of fun. Hell I still rember all my old rally point hides.

Karkand night Or Sharqi night.

GoreZiad wrote:Karkand night Or Sharqi night.

LOL That was one of the reasons i downloaded PR. and i got hooked on the realism.

Helmand Province FTW!!

170 MAP VOTES GREAT POLL

I liked Helmand. It sucked for the insurgents after they lost all their spawncars, though. Running from the spawn to rejoin your squad at the cache wasn't fun. Otherwise, it was interesting because of the combination of buildings and flat fields - not really much cover, but still fun.

Compton was also entertaining. Perhaps not the most balanced map, but it nevertheless played cool from the defensive side, as you tried to hold the trenchlines.

i want new maps. EJOD version 2 would be nice. not that its in production or anything...but i think it would be nice to have a larger city

I loved Operation Phoenix, It was great urban combat and really needed teamwork to take the flag, I would love to see it back in.

Voted Bi Ming night, but would prefer Hills of Hamong reworked