Page 3 of 5

Re: Plane/Jet Brakes

Posted: 2008-07-02 02:43
by Colt556
Um, Tirak. That video shows a plane trying to land on an aircraft carrier, and comming in too low and hitting the front of the ship. If that was the case I wouldn't care. I'm talking about comin in on a runway and sliding off the back cuz the damn thing is too short. Find me a video of a jet landing on a normal runway and either exploding cuz of the impact (Note, not a nose dive, landing on it's wheels and breaking it's wheels and going boom) or sliding right off the end and going boom. I seriously doubt you can find a video of that, but if you do I'll drop that subject.

Also, I play PR for teamwork, but as I said there's a fine line between teamwork, and being useless. If I can't do something myself, there's something wrong. You should be able to do anything yourself, you should do it better with others. THAT's teamwork. NEEDING others in order to do it isn't teamwork, that's dependence. While having my team kill that AAV would be more helpfull, it shouldn't be a requirement, few things should be required if this is reality, after all.

Re: Plane/Jet Brakes

Posted: 2008-07-02 03:02
by Waaah_Wah
Colt556 wrote:What happens if you're too fast to land, but too slow to wave off?
You hold shift and W and gain enough speed to lift up again? Its not rocket science.

If you cant land the aircraft, leave it to others. Thats not rocket science either.

Re: Plane/Jet Brakes

Posted: 2008-07-02 03:07
by Colt556
Waaah_Wah wrote:You hold shift and W and gain enough speed to lift up again? Its not rocket science.

If you cant land the aircraft, leave it to others. Thats not rocket science either.
If you had read my earlier posts I wouldn't have to repeat myself. I know how to land just fine. I have absolutely no trouble with it. My trouble comes in when I don't have the luxury of doing a nice and proper landing, for whatever the reason.

Re: Plane/Jet Brakes

Posted: 2008-07-02 03:11
by Waaah_Wah
Colt556 wrote: The AAV has a range of over a 1000 meters, I know that much is for sure. That means that jet has to get a 1000 meters in the air to escape it. That just aint gonna happen in the ammount of time it'd take that driver to get a lock and fire. So yeah, air assets really don't have anywhere to hide. Maybe from tanks and ground units, but not from AA.

Press X and hold it untill the lock is gone or untill you see the black screen. You are reducing your chance of getting shot down with every flare you drop.

Air assets do have places to hide, I guess. But you can't actually expect the pilot to stay 1500 meters in the air just because there's an AAV or something lurking around.

No... You expect him to fly and look after the AA like a moron :roll:

And that pilot can't exactly land because if he tries he's dead anyways.

Are you sure? Coz ive landed many times in PR.

He can't tell his team where the enemy is because if he knew, he'd kill it.

Exepc aircraft cant do **** without people on the ground in this game. How do you kill an AAV thats not marked with SOFLAM?

So he's essentially stuck, hoping for his team to save him. Now I'm all for teamwork, but there's teamwork, and then there's being an invalid. I shouldn't have to spend the entire round in the clouds because my team is unable to find and destroy an AAV.

Oh yes you should.

I should be able to do a nice, hard landing and hide in my base before that AAV can shoot me down.

WTF? You know, the maps in PR arent so small that you cant hide from AAV's when landing...

I mean really, what do you have against letting pilots do what real life pilots would do? You honestly think a real life pilot couldn't do an emergancy landing if need be? You honestly think a real life pilot would run off the end of the runway, or crash and explode into the ground from 20 meters up? Seriously man, air assets aren't so fragile in real life. And this mod is suppose to be realistic, so jets and heli's need to toughen up, and be able to crash land. Since sometimes crash landing is your only option.
Bold.

EDIT: The runway isnt THAT short. And if your coming in waaaay too fast, you can always bail out to save the aircraft.

Re: Plane/Jet Brakes

Posted: 2008-07-02 03:16
by Waaah_Wah
Colt556 wrote:If you had read my earlier posts I wouldn't have to repeat myself. I know how to land just fine. I have absolutely no trouble with it. My trouble comes in when I don't have the luxury of doing a nice and proper landing, for whatever the reason.
If you can land just fine, then you have nothing to complain about... If you cant do a proper landing for whatever reason, you simply dont land.
I dont think pilots IRL go:

"Aww fuck, i probably wont make this but oh well, lets try."

Re: Plane/Jet Brakes

Posted: 2008-07-02 03:43
by Colt556
Sigh. Ok lets go through this.

1: Flares don't allways help, and what happens if you run out of them?

2: It's kind of rediculous to force the pilot to waste that jet for the entire round because he has no way of running from an AAV, and he nor his team can locate it. :/

3: Nice job taking it out of context. I'm not saying just landing would kill him, I'm saying landing with an AAV, or enemy fighter lurking around would be suicide. Since a nice slow-moving target going in a straight line would be TOO easy for anyone to shoot down.

4: Why should I? Just because it's a team game doesn't mean you have to be useless without someone else. Every player should be able to perform basic tasks on their own, working together should simply enhance it and make it better.

5: The maps are tiny when in a jet, and what happens if the AAV is near the airfield? Hidden behind a hill a thousand meters from the end of the runway? Your team wouldn't see him since people never go in those areas, but that AAV could shoot down any jet trying to take off or land.


And in real life, if that pilots life was in danger, he'd risk a shitty landing to save his life. He wouldn't just, for example, fly around in circles until he was shot down because he didn't wanna risk doing a bad landing. You keep making it sound like we're talking about a civilian airplane at a civilian airport. We're talking about war, and soldiers have to do risky things every day in order to survive. I'm pretty sure a pilot wouldn't hesitate for a second to do a horrible landing if the alternative was certain death.

Re: Plane/Jet Brakes

Posted: 2008-07-02 04:25
by darkwarrior666
Colt556 wrote:4: Why should I? Just because it's a team game doesn't mean you have to be useless without someone else. Every player should be able to perform basic tasks on their own, working together should simply enhance it and make it better.
That sounds like the mindset for base BF2. PR is a team game. If your teammates can't help you(for whatever reason, be it that they're mostly idiots or that the enemy is simply better), then you're boned, no matter what you're in, be it plane, armor, heli, or on foot.

If you can't radio in to your teammates that you need some cover while you come in for a landing, chances are you're gonna get shot down. That's not unrealistic, that's just what happens. If noone's manning the defenses at a US Air Force base, then guess what? Japanese fighters are gonna pick off planes taking off, landing, and not even moving. That's not unrealistic, that's smart tactics.

Re: Plane/Jet Brakes

Posted: 2008-07-02 04:36
by Colt556
I'm not saying that's unreasonable. I'm just saying I shouldn't HAVE to rely on my allies. I should be able to do it on my own, just that's it extremely hard, and that relying on allies gives me a huge bonus. I hate having things limited, and in real life there's nothing forcing a pilot to rely on his allies to help him out. He will because it's the smart thing to do, and it'll help save his life, but he doesn't have to. That's what I was saying.

Re: Plane/Jet Brakes

Posted: 2008-07-02 11:10
by Chanvlan
Tirak wrote:Okay, go here: YouTube - Project Reality Flight Training
Skip ahead to the 4:20 mark and Rhino distinctivly says: "When your speed is pretty low you can also apply the brake with your Taxi Engine by pulling back on your stick, doing this however when your plane is going too fast will make it climb back into the air again, you need to be going slow enough for your plane to stick to the ground so this will be effective."

That is how you brake. You'll also notice in Rhino's video, he stops well short of the edge of the runway and does not land near the begining of the runway, there is pleanty of margin for error it would seem.
ahahaha mate, thats the ?EuroTyphhon? it can land in 10 meters, and take off in that much to ok. Bad map and jet to choose to ddo a vid with, no offence Rihno

Re: Plane/Jet Brakes

Posted: 2008-07-02 11:16
by Chanvlan
Waaah_Wah wrote:Bold.

EDIT: The runway isnt THAT short. And if your coming in waaaay too fast, you can always bail out to save the aircraft.
I do that all the time and it sucks, cause then suome noob comes and takes my aircraft and crashes it at the end of the runway, the onely way to do that effectivly is to have a squady with you to look after the aircraft for ya while you have a 3 hour respawn.

No this post was intentionly made wityhe the purpose of getting a button or a key set to press to slow down the aircraft, like maybe if you held down reverse on the aircraft and also "crlt" or some other ket that it enables the brakes on teh wheels of the aircraft to "lock up" therefore making you speed slow down, like on commercial aircraft i mean sureley they have these on jets, and real runways are normally 1 km long and 2km long where in instances they have HUGE aircraft taking off. Now i dont want a larger runways just some dam wheel brakes!!!! :evil:

Re: Plane/Jet Brakes

Posted: 2008-07-02 13:52
by Waaah_Wah
Colt556 wrote:Sigh. Ok lets go through this.

1: Flares don't allways help, and what happens if you run out of them?

If you run out of them its your own fault for not knowing how many you have left. When you run out of them, you dont fly low, you dont go after the enemy AAV's or jets. When you have very few flares left, you climb to 3-4000 meters and you stay there untill you have 30 fresh flares.

2: It's kind of rediculous to force the pilot to waste that jet for the entire round because he has no way of running from an AAV, and he nor his team can locate it. :/

Like i said, flare and fly straight up. It works in about 70-80% of the times i fly

3: Nice job taking it out of context. I'm not saying just landing would kill him, I'm saying landing with an AAV, or enemy fighter lurking around would be suicide. Since a nice slow-moving target going in a straight line would be TOO easy for anyone to shoot down.

Why the hell would you try to land when theres a fighter behind you?? Also, simply dont play on servers wich allow baserape and you wont have problems with AAVs lurking around your airfield. You could also just pop flares every 2 or so seconds when landing to avoid the lock.

4: Why should I? Just because it's a team game doesn't mean you have to be useless without someone else. Every player should be able to perform basic tasks on their own, working together should simply enhance it and make it better.

And you can perform basic tasks such as shooting down enemy jeps and chopters and strafing.

5: The maps are tiny when in a jet, and what happens if the AAV is near the airfield? Hidden behind a hill a thousand meters from the end of the runway? Your team wouldn't see him since people never go in those areas, but that AAV could shoot down any jet trying to take off or land.

Thats baserape.. But again, it can be avoided by popping flares so he wont get a lock on.

And in real life, if that pilots life was in danger, he'd risk a shitty landing to save his life. He wouldn't just, for example, fly around in circles until he was shot down because he didn't wanna risk doing a bad landing.

IRL an enemy AAV wouldnt be able to get that close to the airfield...

You keep making it sound like we're talking about a civilian airplane at a civilian airport. We're talking about war, and soldiers have to do risky things every day in order to survive. I'm pretty sure a pilot wouldn't hesitate for a second to do a horrible landing if the alternative was certain death.

ejecting would be far safer.
Bold.

Re: Plane/Jet Brakes

Posted: 2008-07-02 13:59
by Waaah_Wah
Colt556 wrote:I'm not saying that's unreasonable. I'm just saying I shouldn't HAVE to rely on my allies. I should be able to do it on my own, just that's it extremely hard, and that relying on allies gives me a huge bonus.

But you can do things on your own in jets in PR. You can land (But its extremely hard), you can bomb (But its extremely hard) andyou can strafe targets (But its extremely hard).

I hate having things limited, and in real life there's nothing forcing a pilot to rely on his allies to help him out.

Hahaha! :lol: :lol: This is brilliant.

He will because it's the smart thing to do, and it'll help save his life, but he doesn't have to. That's what I was saying.

Oh yes he does.
Bold.

Re: Plane/Jet Brakes

Posted: 2008-07-02 17:31
by Colt556
We're getting off topic regardless. The jets should have brakes, it'd be a simple add and help out. It doesn't hurt gameplay in the least and allows for some wiggle-room when landing. Pure and simple.

Re: Plane/Jet Brakes

Posted: 2008-07-02 21:53
by Chanvlan
Colt556 wrote:We're getting off topic regardless. The jets should have brakes, it'd be a simple add and help out. It doesn't hurt gameplay in the least and allows for some wiggle-room when landing. Pure and simple.
ThankGOD the bikering comes to an end, now i made this post in response to something that could be easily added as mention by colt into the game. Some brakes on aircraft so as SOON as they land (not waiting to slow down first) they can apply "whhel brakes" which lock up their weehls HENCE slowing them down better! comment on if THIS is possible NOT WHETHER IT IS FREAKING NEEDED CAUSE IT IS@!!!!! :evil:


STAY ON TOPIC DAMMIT! :mrgreen:

Re: Plane/Jet Brakes

Posted: 2008-07-02 22:12
by Tirak
Alright, you want on topic, PAY ATTENTION! The plane has brakes, any other sort of brake besides what has already been placed on the jet is impossible to do without bringing back reverse thrust, this thread has become nothing more than me posting the answer to your original post, you bitching, and Waah Wah egging you on. the heart of the matter is landing jets in your mind is too hard and you're too thick to ask for support if there is something that can make life dificult for you.

And Chanvlan, yes the Eurofighter is the easiest to land, but that map is the hardest to land on, additionaly, Rhino hit the middle of the runway and stopped three quarters of the way down, so if you land anywhere in the first quarter or third of the runway with just about any jet, you should be fine, and the J10 doesn't count as a counter example because the Devs have admited to screwing up on that one.

Re: Plane/Jet Brakes

Posted: 2008-07-02 22:20
by Colt556
Tirak wrote:Alright, you want on topic, PAY ATTENTION! The plane has brakes, any other sort of brake besides what has already been placed on the jet is impossible to do without bringing back reverse thrust, this thread has become nothing more than me posting the answer to your original post, you bitching, and Waah Wah egging you on. the heart of the matter is landing jets in your mind is too hard and you're too thick to ask for support if there is something that can make life dificult for you.

And Chanvlan, yes the Eurofighter is the easiest to land, but that map is the hardest to land on, additionaly, Rhino hit the middle of the runway and stopped three quarters of the way down, so if you land anywhere in the first quarter or third of the runway with just about any jet, you should be fine, and the J10 doesn't count as a counter example because the Devs have admited to screwing up on that one.
I don't have problems landing lol. I've never botched up a landing outside of my first training landings. Stop assuming I'm just some noob crying because I can't do something in the game, seriously. I, personally, have had no problems with any of the scenerarios I presented, I was just trying to get the point across that sometimes the unexepected pops up and you can't land perfectly, and so come in a little fast.

If you read what I've been saying, and stopped assuming things, I wouldn't have to repeat myself endlessly. Furthermore, until an actual dev says it's not possible without reverse thrust, I'll just think it is. I mean no offense man, but I don't recall you coding anything for the mod, so how do you know what it and isn't possible?

Re: Plane/Jet Brakes

Posted: 2008-07-02 22:45
by Tirak
Wait a sec, why am I arguing with you, this thread is a resuggestion, I should be making a witty comment about you not using the search feature. There is a brake, now I've said all I'm going to say on the subject until a mod locks this for resuggestion.

https://www.realitymod.com/forum/f18-pr ... craft.html
https://www.realitymod.com/forum/f18-pr ... lanes.html

Re: Plane/Jet Brakes

Posted: 2008-07-03 00:18
by darkwarrior666
Colt556 wrote:I'm not saying that's unreasonable. I'm just saying I shouldn't HAVE to rely on my allies. I should be able to do it on my own, just that's it extremely hard, and that relying on allies gives me a huge bonus.
And that's how it is right now. You can land under said conditions, but guess what? It'll be extremely hard. Not impossible, just hard as f*ck to pull off.

I mean, don't get me wrong, I agree with the idea of wheel brakes and air brakes on jets. But your main arguement isn't sound.

Re: Plane/Jet Brakes

Posted: 2008-07-03 01:53
by Chanvlan
Tirak wrote:Wait a sec, why am I arguing with you, this thread is a resuggestion, I should be making a witty comment about you not using the search feature. There is a brake, now I've said all I'm going to say on the subject until a mod locks this for resuggestion.
there is a brake your rite, and no this isnt RESUGGESTION cause i have searched. Now all there is needed is a brake that works when your not going 20km/h also dont reply to this cause you siad you wouldnt Tirak!

"now I've said all I'm going to say on the subject" -Tirak

Re: Plane/Jet Brakes

Posted: 2008-07-03 13:57
by @bsurd
i agree with kind of breaks to.

But sry colt, but your comments a a little bit... Dont know the word now. But if there is a jet on your ***, dont try to land. think what happend if you get it landed. The e jet turns, comes back and blow you away on the runway/ground...

And if you say you cant get away from an AAV, your are not a good pilot.

Its hard to fly, and land, thats all. So train it.

Last time i played we have an a 10 pilot on kashan who knows his job. And with the help of the team (mark everything you see) he takes out everything. And i mean everything! Inf, e jets, e ground attack jets, enemy tanks and e aav...As pilot you need a good team on the ground.

I for myself loaded the training mod and spent nights alone on a map and the only thing i trained is land, start again, land and so on. Next i trained is how to take out the targets very quickly and how to attack them the best way. (I make a 10 training @ the moment)

And i dont think in RL a jet Pilot try´s to land under so hot conditions you are talking about.

Think what happend if you crash a fighter plane on an airport... Thats a big boom and more then the pilot who dies...

And i for myself dont shot all my ammo and then go rearm. I ever hold a rocket back so if i get attacked bye a landing sequence, i go full trottle and back in fight... And then when all is clear i land ...

Kind of breaks would be nice, but i see such good pilots out there they dont need it...so it is possible to be the overkiller in a jet without changes.