Muttrah City v0.91 Feedback

[Shredhead99]

Checked it, still 100%. As I said, I haven't been the only one to hear those soundbugs.

[PLODDITHANLEY]

Can anyone confirm if i've got this right, I've read the whole thread but it's not straightforward to work out:

US start:
Attack Huey No respawn
4 X Slick (Vietnam influence) 3 respawn
2 X LAV
2 X Boats

20 mins spawn
Cobra


Respawning vehicles
3 X Slicks 10 min
2 X LAV 10 min
2 X Boats 5 mins?
Cobra 20 mins
Truck 5 mins


MEC Start:
4 X Squad Trucks No respawns
1 X BRDM trans (how many seats has this got?) No respawn

When South is capped
2 X Logy trucks 5 mins
1 X UAV jeep 5 mins
Delayed spawn (10mins) after South City is capped
3 X APC 10 mins
1 X BRDM .50 cal 10 mins

[Moonlight]

I'm pretty sure that respawn time on hueys is 5 minutes while on LAVs - 10. Same should go for MEC BTRs and an armed BRDM - 10 minute spawntime.
Dunno about the trucks but they tend to respawn 5 minute after they're destoyed, I didn't check if it's different on Muttrah though.
Futhermore I higly doubt if it's even possible to make an asset respawn only twice. I mean that could be 2 different hueys appearing after certain time and not respwning, but what that would be for?

[PLODDITHANLEY]

Muttrah City (v2) v0.91 GPO Update - Project Reality Forums


Read the beginning of this thread from Rhino he states:

For the USMC I've basically reverted back to the old setup, attack huey spawning at the start with no respawn and replaced with a cobra later in the game on a 20min spawn delay. Only thing different from .87 is that instead of having two little birds that don't respawn I've replaced them with anouther Huey that doesn't respawn and also made one of the re spawning hueys (out of two) have a max number of 2 two spawn. Also the USMC do have the vehicle depo and the logi truck that spawns once the docks is capped like before.

Not very clear....

[Rhino]

Basically it means there are only two spawn points, but one of the spawn points can spawn in two active choppers, giving a total of 3 hueys being able to respawn.

[Spartan0189]

I guess I'll post my feedback too

I like it, both teams are evenly matched when they are capping docks (Or well, that is from my perspective) or the other flags, It doesn't really matter how many assets there are, it's all about how much the team spends getting ready for an attack on the first flag.

Otherwise, I think the map is a lot better now (Or how it was in previous versions), and it makes it more fair for the USMC to move onto docks.

Again, it just matters on how much time the team spends preparing.

[Mutherpucker]

i noticed one problem
attack huey and cobra spawns at the same spot on the carrier. i was playing with verry few people on the map so heavy assets werent used. when the cobra spawned, attack huey just exploded under the cobra, thus USMC loosing tickets just becouse noone bothered to move the chopper. can you set the attk huey to spawn on the north side of the carrier, so this thing doesent happen anymore. its not a big problem but it still costs US side tickets for no reason

yup, confirmed, I saw that happened;Cobra makes cas huey explode. A simple repositioning where the cas huey was before, at it would rule that out.




Balanced map btw, good job

Lemme be a pain in the **** a bit tho

2 cas huey was a blast to be and watch, I would put them back... respawnable.
Cobra would spawn, 20 minutes later, one shot as in not respawnable.
And to balance the 2 respawnable cas huey, I would grant MEC a Heavy tank, after 20 minute. As if to make it respawnable... I really don't know, maybe it would be balanced to make it respawnable, maybe it would only be a fair chance for both side if it wasn't respawnable, to introduce it at the same time (20 minutes) as the cobra.

But, greatly improved, good job.


Oh, and 1 more thing, flags postitions are PERFECT IMO. I saw many, many battles on muttrah 24/7 =HOG= and the action move from 1 flag to the other so fast it's great, there is no bottleneck that way. Just perfect.

[Scared_420]

i know this should probably go in the feedback section but i didnt know if it should be in vehicles or maps so here it is...

i find that usa are under equipped now against the mec on muttrah city, with the deployable tows and 4 14.5mm vehicles versus the usa's 2 lav's i think there should be a tank that spawns at the docks, however it should spawn only once like the atk hueys

the air assets are perfect in my opinion for usa but the problem is noob pilots who go in for a hellfire spam and then die after the first straffe, also with the lav's is that it takes about 4-5 minutes to get to shore and then they get rocked by a tow

the only problem i can see with having a tank is its not very realistic as the map is based on a seaborne invasion but i think its deffinately something that should be looked at if not tested out

[Rudd]

the USA can get supplies to multiple locations very fast, allowing them to build their own TOWs etc so I don't think the USA need a tank

right now the asset balance of that map is as perfect as it can be I think.

[Scared_420]

not necessarily, when the btrs are spread out evenly along the coast line it makes it incredibly difficult for the choppers to make supply drops into the city

[Rudd]

not necessarily, when the btrs are spread out evenly along the coast line it makes it incredibly difficult for the choppers to make supply drops into the city

when that happens I like to go behind the mountains and then come over the top to accelerate fast, go low, drop, then get out back over the mountains skimming the map edge.

and if the MEC APCs are all on the coast, then that means they aren't fighting your men....which means they don't need AT atm

The MEC can beat the USMC with the right tactics, teh USMC can defeat the MEC with the right tactics, its not supposed to be USMC get advantage to win all the time. Its balanced now with great gameplay

[Rhino]

not necessarily, when the btrs are spread out evenly along the coast line it makes it incredibly difficult for the choppers to make supply drops into the city

And if the USMC aint managed to setup some good firebases etc before the BTRs spawn then they deserve what they get

[Smegburt_funkledink]

Cobra??

[Scared_420]

rudd you are right about going behind the mountains but then the usa are limited to fob's on the far west of the map and when AA gets setup near construcion it takes care of the huey pilots

[Rudd]

yes Sacred, how dare the MEC use strategy and teamwork to defeat you.

[TheOldBreed]

it would be interesting to see the MEC have a tank instead. like one BTR and a tank. would be pretty nuts.

[kaufman_23]

tank in a city? bad idea. ask the russians

the balance of muttrah is perfect. the only thing i would add is a couple of humves that would spawn on repair station. maybe a transport one and another one with a 50 cal. to give more mobility to usmc while on ground

[K4on]

the balance of muttrah is perfect. the only thing i would add is a couple of humves that would spawn on repair station. maybe a transport one and another one with a 50 cal. to give more mobility to usmc while on ground

i'm missing the good old vodnik...
i know it won't happen, but if usmc would get their hummvies, mecs should revive their vodniks again

[Scared_420]

i think if the tank was confined to the docks area it would help usa out a lot more and prenevt dock rushing which always ends the map with a bleed which is why it should be unspawnable and only get one,,, however i don't agree on the humvee's spawning at repair station as the hueys would then be rendered useless

[Psyrus]

I disagree with the US getting a tank, but I would support the replacement of one BTR with a T72 or the like, but honestly I think it is superbly balanced as it is.

I second everything that Rudd has said so far