Map Loading Music Lacks Martial Spirit
Posted: 2012-08-04 19:56
This is REALLY nit picking so feel free to totally ignore this.. but ive been playing PR for years (and still love it) and this is just something thats always bothered me.
The map loading music is not inspiring at all.
This is not to say its not good music. I can appreciate the work thats gone into the soundtrack. I just dont feel it puts you in a fighting mood. Usually I just mute all the music because I was finding it dull.
Im not sure what the devs intended but I think that the time when a map is loading is a great time to play some music that will get people into the 'zone' or mood or whatever of the game. You have to wait anyway, so why not use music to rev up the player, start the immersion, build a little tension.
For example Project Reality 0.95 - Soundtrack - Loading Music 1 - YouTube Its really nice music. I could have a nap, take a bath with candles, or get a nice massage to that music...but it doesnt really make me want to jump into combat. Elsewhere in the game music has been used well. Qom playing in the bombcars really seems to add mood. www.tawhed.de Qom Nasheed - YouTube
If you listen to the vanilla BF2 music, even though it was cheezy, it was at least upbeat and left you feeling more engaged.
Some of the best 'get ready to fight music' was in BF:Vietnam. I still cant listen to Fortunate Son without picturing Huey's warming up
Battlefield Vietnam Intro Movie Clip - YouTube
(i understand theres not really a budget to hire Creedence to do the soundtrack
)
Another good example of music that puts you in a fighting mood was the Hell March from Red Alert
C&C Red Alert music (Hell March) - YouTube
Finally (and im not sure if this is ironic.. or just odd) one of the best examples of music that puts me in a combat mood is War - by Edwin Star... Makes you want to get up.. grab a gun.. and er... stop wars
Edwin Starr - War (What Is It Good For?) - YouTube
Anyway thats just my opinion. As I said.. REALLY minor issue from a game I have been loving for years.
[ED: I couldnt figure out how to get the youtube tag to work :/]
The map loading music is not inspiring at all.
This is not to say its not good music. I can appreciate the work thats gone into the soundtrack. I just dont feel it puts you in a fighting mood. Usually I just mute all the music because I was finding it dull.
Im not sure what the devs intended but I think that the time when a map is loading is a great time to play some music that will get people into the 'zone' or mood or whatever of the game. You have to wait anyway, so why not use music to rev up the player, start the immersion, build a little tension.
For example Project Reality 0.95 - Soundtrack - Loading Music 1 - YouTube Its really nice music. I could have a nap, take a bath with candles, or get a nice massage to that music...but it doesnt really make me want to jump into combat. Elsewhere in the game music has been used well. Qom playing in the bombcars really seems to add mood. www.tawhed.de Qom Nasheed - YouTube
If you listen to the vanilla BF2 music, even though it was cheezy, it was at least upbeat and left you feeling more engaged.
Some of the best 'get ready to fight music' was in BF:Vietnam. I still cant listen to Fortunate Son without picturing Huey's warming up
Battlefield Vietnam Intro Movie Clip - YouTube
(i understand theres not really a budget to hire Creedence to do the soundtrack
Another good example of music that puts you in a fighting mood was the Hell March from Red Alert
C&C Red Alert music (Hell March) - YouTube
Finally (and im not sure if this is ironic.. or just odd) one of the best examples of music that puts me in a combat mood is War - by Edwin Star... Makes you want to get up.. grab a gun.. and er... stop wars
Edwin Starr - War (What Is It Good For?) - YouTube
Anyway thats just my opinion. As I said.. REALLY minor issue from a game I have been loving for years.
[ED: I couldnt figure out how to get the youtube tag to work :/]