Project Reality Forums

This may have been suggested or shot down before, I don't know.

But I'll cut straight to the chase; vehicle gunnery (with the exception of mounted 12.7mm/7.62mm guns on the FAV/Vodnik/HMMWV/etc) needs to be default controlled with the 'WASD' keys.



It may be possible do this by altering the controls from the options, I haven't tried so I don't really know. But it needs to be made so that (like the ZIS-3 from some of the militia maps) controlled using the 'WASD' keys.

Not only is this much more realistic to controlling a real tank (generally moving on only one axis at a time), but makes the game look more realistic, and makes it more balanced. No longer will it be so damn easy to shoot down helicopters with the tanks main gun (I understand this can happen in real life, but it isn't likely to happen as much as in PR), I'd even say it's easier to shoot down helicopters with the main gun in PR than it is in vBF2 (mainly due to the zoom).

The only issue I see with this, is A: I don't know if people could just edit their options and make it go back to mouse-aiming, this making the game unbalanced for newbies because they have to use the much more realistic 'WASD' method, and issue B: you would need to make the AA vehicles manned by 2 instead of one (which should have been done along time ago anyhow).

Of course, this is also concerning the APC/IFV pool too.

I really think this would make PR a much more realistic and balanced experience.

But, let's hear everyone else thoughts.

I kinda agree with you

Hey hey this guy must be related to M Warren good suggestion

i picture 1337 nme spec ops running circles around apcs/tanks creaming their pants coz they cant hit em

Well then you get the gunner on top to hose him, thats what its for

haha through but then you have to have a .50 on top.

if this is more like the tank controls IRL, i'm all for it, realistic turret movement ftw

Zimmer wrote:haha through but then you have to have a .50 on top.

true, true. i just wanted to be a little defaetist

what about the poor militia though..

I remember asking a DEV about this also, but the response i recieved was 'Hard coded'.
Im not sure how true this stands today, so I will leave this thread open for a insighted response, despite being suggested before.

...mongol...

Red Orchestra has this system of Turret-movement.

It works out well. It's very easy to keep the turret steady, especially when moving.


Honestly, I'd like to see better handling regarding armor, considering when going over somewhat uneven ground you bounce more than a crackhead naked on a trampoline with springs on the bottom of his shoes.


I'd like to see it, but I don't think it'd be possible. But I obviously could be very wrong.

Armor is going to get owned hard with these controls. Then again, I guess whoever bumps up the turret sensitivity the most would win.

AT-cannons on Fools Road also have these controls..

Sounds good. People with a high dpi mouse otherwise have an uber advantage and it would in my opinion make it more realistic.

Maybe use the arrow keys instead? That way it can work for the AAVs.

I dislike the idea. I have tried it on other games, and I can't seem to hit the side of a barn (you also lose some acute control - think if an arrowtap moved you 2 pixels but you needed a one pixel move). If it was compatible with a joystick, I might reconsider it.

Turret turn rates are coded in, so the better mouse doesn't have an advantage, I'd like to see WASD as secondary controls, but keep the mouse so that fine aiming can be done.

Tirak wrote:Turret turn rates are coded in, so the better mouse doesn't have an advantage

Doesn't seem to help. Logitech G9's five-step sensitivity adjustment works wonders on turret turn speeds. I use 200 dpi on max zoom to get pinpoint accuracy and 3200 dpi without zoom to get that thing turn.

sounds awesome, much more realistic sounding =D

I don't really think this is such a good idea. First of all, while in real tanks you don't get a mouse, you usually get an analog control stick or something of that kind to allow you to precisely control the turret. If you had just four keys to control the turret movement, you wouldn't have that sort of control. You wouldn't be able to quickly turn the turret around while still retaining the ability to make very small adjustments when firing. You'd have to have a compromise somewhere in between, and that's not what happens in real life. Turrets of modern MBTs are capable of quick movement for a reason.

Second of all, in real life, turrets are stabilized. Yes, we have some stabilization in PR, but for the most part, it sucks. Nobody fires on the run anyway. Fortunately, having mouse controls allows us to make minor adjustments to compensate for bumpiness more easily.

On top of that, I use ESDF.

I like this idea , i played Red Orchestra 2 with the Tank and it works fine.