Page 1 of 3

Question to the Public.

Posted: 2011-03-29 14:54
by Tiger1
We are trying to make a list of the most popular Project Reality maps.

A so called top notch server map list.


My question to the public (that means you) is the following ;


What is your favourite map? And why?



After we've gotten a lot of replies to this thread we will look at the results and create a 'near perfect server map list'.





Yours respectfully,



SSG Andersson.

Re: Question to the Public.

Posted: 2011-03-29 14:55
by Doc.Pock
yey first post. Mutrah, kashan, jabal, qwai
dunno why i just like them

Re: Question to the Public.

Posted: 2011-03-29 15:08
by Swaggzor
probably Kokan, because i love insurgency and this map is ideal for fast hit and run humvee attacks. Otherwise it would be fallujah west because i just love the setting in which you have to TAKE the city house by house(and its INS ofcourse hehe)

Re: Question to the Public.

Posted: 2011-03-29 15:12
by snotmaster0
People are gonna hate this, but Kashan 32. In my humble opinion its the best combined arms map for PR.

Re: Question to the Public.

Posted: 2011-03-29 15:37
by Cheiftain_UK
I personally love Silent Eagle, first fo all its a 4km map yet it also has lots of small engagements, It is good for vehicles and transport chopper pilots (like me :p ) yet infantry can also enjoy it when fighting over the central village, Its also one of the few maps where lazing is actively used.

Re: Question to the Public.

Posted: 2011-03-29 15:41
by PatrickLA_CA
Kashan 32, Muttrah, Jabal, Qwai inf (aas just sucks(unbalanced)), karbala, silent eagle, burning sands, Iron eagle, Al Basrah, Kokan, Korengal, Barracuda, Lashkar, Northern Lights.

Re: Question to the Public.

Posted: 2011-03-29 15:41
by declan54321
Cheiftain_UK wrote:I personally love Silent Eagle, first fo all its a 4km map yet it also has lots of small engagements, It is good for vehicles and transport chopper pilots (like me :p ) yet infantry can also enjoy it when fighting over the central village, Its also one of the few maps where lazing is actively used.
Yeah, I like Silent Eagle and Muttrah for flying helis :)

I also enjoy playing other maps such as Dragon Fly (As Brits), and Fallujah West (As a Civi :)

Re: Question to the Public.

Posted: 2011-03-29 15:44
by splatters
Good old Kashan Desert! There is nothing that can beat a good, open and honest combined arms map, though the inf layer isn't bad either. It's also one of the few maps left that low end computers can run with little performance issues.

Of course there are many brilliant maps but when it comes to choosing your all time favourite it's Kashan Desert for sure.

Re: Question to the Public.

Posted: 2011-03-29 15:58
by saXoni
Muttrah City - Cobra
Kashan Desert 32 - Havok/Apache
Kashan Desert 64 - F16
Silent Eagle - Eurofighter
Iron Eagle - Havok/Apache
Jabal - Hueys
Kokan - Kiowa, Blufor INF

Re: Question to the Public.

Posted: 2011-03-29 16:05
by H.Maverick
Muttrah City- helicopter, armor and infantry in an urban map :D i just fu**ing love it :D

Re: Question to the Public.

Posted: 2011-03-29 16:17
by goguapsy
I am a HUGE fan of insurgency maps, specially Karbala (my fav :D ), Ramiel, Operation Archer, Fallujah West and Kokan. Any size, but normally 64 is pretty awesome, balanced (insurgency-wise) and fun!

For AAS, I'd probably go with Muttrah City. And I find Qwai pretty awesome (no tanks version though, I like the 32 I think, more balanced?)

Re: Question to the Public.

Posted: 2011-03-29 16:27
by saXoni
Do you guys really find it that hard to kill the tank on Qwai?

Re: Question to the Public.

Posted: 2011-03-29 16:50
by Freakerr38
Muttrah City

Re: Question to the Public.

Posted: 2011-03-29 17:01
by No_Surrender
AAS:
- Muttrah City
- Beirut
- Asad Khal

Insurgency:
- Fallujah West
- Gaza Beach
- Korengal Valley
- Kokan
- Lashkar Valley

IDF maps rules!

Re: Question to the Public.

Posted: 2011-03-29 17:08
by -CJ-
Asad Khal (AKA epic'er Helmand ) !



Depend on round but imo any can be nice if you play with a good squad and good team. (teamwork + mumble).


Don't know if it's only me but I feel there is too much "unbalanced" map. I know that's what we want, for realism, different gameplay but I like when the 2 factions got similar equipements. I still love to play insurgency and some "unbalanced" map but imo there is too much of them


sorry for my english :? ??:

Re: Question to the Public.

Posted: 2011-03-29 17:15
by Wadziu
Beirut because of epic and balanced CQB and that very tall building :-P

Re: Question to the Public.

Posted: 2011-03-29 17:35
by Irishchoctaw1015
Anything but kashan, iron eagle, or qinling.

Favorite: Probably either muttrah or silent eagle.

Re: Question to the Public.

Posted: 2011-03-29 17:49
by ryan d ale
Gaza - It is under played and usually very fun.

Operation Marlin - Was very fun and should be great.

Quinling - Combined arms and so a role for everyone.

British vs MEC over a city and some Oilfields? Can't remember the name of it...the new one thatrecently had an optimisation test. Lot's of good action.

Dragon Fly - Great tactical and strategic map.

Iron Ridge - Another great tactical and strategic map.

Iron Eagle - Under played and when I have played it I am never disappointed.

Fool's Road - Beautiful map, simple to SL on and great action whatever class you are.

Fallujah West - One of the maybe 2? maps that Iraqi Insurgents get (along with Ramiel) where the blufor only have very limited camping space available! Insurgency is usually a sad campfest of blufor vehicles and waiting the weekend to spot the blufor infantry in the city(exaggeration).

Beirut - Same reasons as most people like Muttrah however I actually enjoy this map and have not been sickened by how many times I've played it.

Re: Question to the Public.

Posted: 2011-03-29 18:03
by Arc_Shielder
I actually had this idea before. People would rate maps through +2;+1;0;-1;-2 points to the official maplist (every layer too) and then the op would update each entry in the scoreboard.

The way it is now, is no different than multiple other "what is your fav map?" threads. You can get a "feeling" from this, not concrete data.

Re: Question to the Public.

Posted: 2011-03-29 18:11
by Tiger1
Arcturus Shielder that's a valid point.

Any replies from now on should be answered like so :


You give every map a number from the scale 1-10.
10 is your absolute favorite map(s). 1 being your least favorite one.