Too Many Chinooks on Yamalia

Post Reply
StuTika
Posts: 255
Joined: 2008-11-30 16:36

Too Many Chinooks on Yamalia

Post by StuTika »

Just come off a round playing Yamalia. I was in the heli transport squad.

Quite simply, 4 Chinooks is too many for such a small main base, and anyway too many for the map.

Even during the initial rush, only 2 were ever airborne at once and the rest of the time 1 was enough, with the other 2-3 pilots twiddling their thumbs most of the time.

The main is also too small for 4 large helis. We were forever bumping into each other on takeoff and landing.
Rudd
Retired PR Developer
Posts: 21225
Joined: 2007-08-15 14:32

Re: Too Many Chinooks on Yamalia

Post by Rudd »

I suspect the intention of teh mapper was to have only as many chinooks manned as necessary, rather than every single asset being used at the same time. My prefered method is to have the minimum number of assets avaliable at any given time for 32 people. However there is a huge advantage in having spare assets as it means that the pilot/crewman of the vehicle that gets destroyed can get the next one without much delay, which keeps the gameplay moving as well as allaying frustration from flips/destruction due to unavoidable things such as lag. though this does lower the value of individual assets. So there's arguements both ways. My main complaint is the lack of markings for the helipads :) But on the maps I'm working on I'm using a Helipad spline texture which seems to work fine for showing helicopter landing zones without sticking out too much. Maybe other mappers will adopt it.

such markings might help your air traffic control as well, but tbh if your colliding with eachother on takeoff you might want to modify your landing pattern.
Image
User avatar
Zrix
Posts: 4425
Joined: 2005-12-02 14:25

Re: Too Many Chinooks on Yamalia

Post by Zrix »

Could have sworn there are only 3 Chinooks on Yamalia.

But in either case, it's all about coordination. Try to get the pilots in one squad, and talk to each other to keep the air clear. And try to stick to your own little area.
Image
myles
Posts: 1614
Joined: 2008-11-09 14:34

Re: Too Many Chinooks on Yamalia

Post by myles »

[R-CON]Rudd wrote:I suspect the intention of teh mapper was to have only as many chinooks manned as necessary, rather than every single asset being used at the same time. My prefered method is to have the minimum number of assets avaliable at any given time for 32 people. However there is a huge advantage in having spare assets as it means that the pilot/crewman of the vehicle that gets destroyed can get the next one without much delay,
That also leads to careless pilots flying now that if they crash or getting shot they dont have to wait too long for a new 1
Check out my Project Reaity gamplay here http://www.youtube.com/user/Projectreality1

Image
l|Bubba|l
Posts: 646
Joined: 2007-03-25 03:40

Re: Too Many Chinooks on Yamalia

Post by l|Bubba|l »

Zrix wrote:Could have sworn there are only 3 Chinooks on Yamalia.

But in either case, it's all about coordination. Try to get the pilots in one squad, and talk to each other to keep the air clear. And try to stick to your own little area.
You're right.
There are only 3 Chinooks on Yamalia
Pariel
Posts: 1584
Joined: 2008-01-29 23:41

Re: Too Many Chinooks on Yamalia

Post by Pariel »

myles wrote:That also leads to careless pilots flying now that if they crash or getting shot they dont have to wait too long for a new 1
If people can't learn that losing assets means losing tickets, that's their problem.

It still helps the team to have lots of assets, especially on a 4km map.
snooggums
Posts: 1093
Joined: 2008-01-26 06:33

Re: Too Many Chinooks on Yamalia

Post by snooggums »

For maps with lots of choppers that spawn near each other and have a bit of open area nearby, like on a carrier, an organized two pilot squad should park the unused vehicles out of harms way to open up the landing area and then take them as needed.

I like parking the two extra transport hueys on carriers by the central tower where nothing spawns, leaving a large repair area for the two active choppers. Doesn't work too well on Gaza (I might be thinking of Beruit), where there are 5(!) choppers packed onto that little Russian ship with nowhere to park spares if I recall correctly, and it is hard enough not catching the tail on a railing and flipping. Removing one or two, the one on the helipad should be removed first and leave the area for repairs, would go a long way to making the choppers more landing friendly.
Vulcan617
Posts: 4
Joined: 2010-04-29 18:28

Re: Too Many Chinooks on Yamalia

Post by Vulcan617 »

I have played on 2 versions of Yamalia and one had 3 chinooks and one had 4, not sure which was which though and the first i played yesterday definitely had 4, definitely.
StuTika
Posts: 255
Joined: 2008-11-30 16:36

Re: Too Many Chinooks on Yamalia

Post by StuTika »

[R-CON]Rudd wrote:I suspect the intention of teh mapper was to have only as many chinooks manned as necessary, rather than every single asset being used at the same time. My prefered method is to have the minimum number of assets avaliable at any given time for 32 people. However there is a huge advantage in having spare assets as it means that the pilot/crewman of the vehicle that gets destroyed can get the next one without much delay, which keeps the gameplay moving as well as allaying frustration from flips/destruction due to unavoidable things such as lag. though this does lower the value of individual assets. So there's arguements both ways. My main complaint is the lack of markings for the helipads :) But on the maps I'm working on I'm using a Helipad spline texture which seems to work fine for showing helicopter landing zones without sticking out too much. Maybe other mappers will adopt it.

such markings might help your air traffic control as well, but tbh if your colliding with eachother on takeoff you might want to modify your landing pattern.

Parking spare Chinooks out of the way is a good point, never thought of that. Solves a lot of problems.
Startrekern
Posts: 847
Joined: 2008-08-31 21:11

Re: Too Many Chinooks on Yamalia

Post by Startrekern »

snooggums wrote:For maps with lots of choppers that spawn near each other and have a bit of open area nearby, like on a carrier, an organized two pilot squad should park the unused vehicles out of harms way to open up the landing area and then take them as needed.

I like parking the two extra transport hueys on carriers by the central tower where nothing spawns, leaving a large repair area for the two active choppers. Doesn't work too well on Gaza (I might be thinking of Beruit), where there are 5(!) choppers packed onto that little Russian ship with nowhere to park spares if I recall correctly, and it is hard enough not catching the tail on a railing and flipping. Removing one or two, the one on the helipad should be removed first and leave the area for repairs, would go a long way to making the choppers more landing friendly.
Agr, personal pet peeve is when people park their hueys on the runway, ESPECIALLY on Jabal where if you take damage, since the carrier is lower than the rest of the map, the best way to survive is to come in really quick on the runway and slide into a landing. Doesn't really work if people are in the way though.
Deer
Posts: 1603
Joined: 2005-03-17 09:31

Re: Too Many Chinooks on Yamalia

Post by Deer »

Depends on how good pilots are and how much enemy has Anti-air weapons, but for some cases it would be better to have 50% less assets and 50% faster respawn rate, that way you would have almost same amount of choppers per 10minutes, but less pilots =) and more men to the front.. or 1 extra combat vehicle for example.

However extra choppers benefit is that that way pilots has alot more extratime to deliver supply boxes and therefore your team should averagely have little more firebases.
Last edited by Deer on 2010-05-11 18:38, edited 5 times in total.
snooggums
Posts: 1093
Joined: 2008-01-26 06:33

Re: Too Many Chinooks on Yamalia

Post by snooggums »

Startrekern wrote:Agr, personal pet peeve is when people park their hueys on the runway, ESPECIALLY on Jabal where if you take damage, since the carrier is lower than the rest of the map, the best way to survive is to come in really quick on the runway and slide into a landing. Doesn't really work if people are in the way though.
If you park it near the tower not only is there a ton of space to land next to the parked chopper along the long runway, but you have the entire front and back sections that are much more clear and longer than the spot near the tower and they will even repair that damaged chopper when it lands while the section by the tower does not.
Post Reply

Return to “Maps”