No firemode indicator while zoomed

KingKong.CCCP
Posts: 396
Joined: 2006-10-25 08:13

Re: No firemode indicator while zoomed

Post by KingKong.CCCP »

My two cents...

Firemode indicator on the screen is completely unnecessary altogether, so put fire mode indicator on SCROLL/NUM LOCK leds on the keyboard!.
Remove it completely from the screen, together with the annoying HUD. Make Project Reality more real.
I personally would like to see on my screen only and nothing else but what a soldier can see with his own eyes.
Ninja2dan
Retired PR Developer
Posts: 2213
Joined: 2007-10-29 03:09

Re: No firemode indicator while zoomed

Post by Ninja2dan »

KingKong.CCCP wrote:My two cents...

Firemode indicator on the screen is completely unnecessary altogether, so put fire mode indicator on SCROLL/NUM LOCK leds on the keyboard!.
Remove it completely from the screen, together with the annoying HUD. Make Project Reality more real.
I personally would like to see on my screen only and nothing else but what a soldier can see with his own eyes.
Sight is only one of many senses used in the real world. In reality you can feel, smell, hear, and even taste the environment and use that sensory feedback to know what's going on around you. But in the game world, you are stuck with a small fixed screen, usually only a 2.1 speaker system or "simulated surround" headphones, and your keyboard/mouse. The on-screen UI is necessary in a gaming environment in order to simulate those things that you are unable to see, hear, or feel.

It's good to keep the UI simple and small enough that it doesn't intrude too much, but it's still needed. And as long as the UI is limited to providing only the feedback that a person would normally be able to obtain from his senses, then I see no problem with it.
Image
pr|Zer0
Posts: 300
Joined: 2008-06-30 12:10

Re: No firemode indicator while zoomed

Post by pr|Zer0 »

If on AR/M16 you can feel the selector, on AK you look at it before you aim. This is how things are done by trained soldiers, plus they are ALWAYS put the weapon on semi when ready to fire(selector all the way down).
A simple "A" or "S" somewhere on the screen should do the job.
Image
CommunistComma
Posts: 377
Joined: 2009-12-28 21:52

Re: No firemode indicator while zoomed

Post by CommunistComma »

doop-de-doo wrote:Thank you for creating this thread.

I don't know how many times I've died because I had to unscope to check which fire mode I was.
IKR. I'm just hoping somebody in charge of something shows up and chimes in instead of just Sgt. Milsim, so this issue can be addressed.
Dulce et decorum est pro patria mori
Image
CopyCat
Posts: 353
Joined: 2010-12-24 19:02

Re: No firemode indicator while zoomed

Post by CopyCat »

Or depending on the map and your experience you put the fire mode you think will be needed in most cases - For example I always have Automatic/Burst fire on for any scenario where I might bump into enemy toe to toe, and then most of the times on long range fire fights where either you spot enemy or he spots you, you switch over to single for to fire. Basically usually I don't know what about you guys but I usually remember the fire mode I have. No problems...

/CC
KiloJules
Posts: 792
Joined: 2011-03-17 18:03

Re: No firemode indicator while zoomed

Post by KiloJules »

1. As far as I can tell we kinda agreed on the possibility to feel to selected firemode IRL.

2. The firemode indicator in game is super small. It is/it would be in an area which you usually do not look while aiming, so it shouldn't really be a problem/obstrusive/disturbing.

3. ???

4. Please integrate it - for the realism - as it, like Ninja2dan said, widens your in game horizon and brings it up to reality.
MrTomRobs
Posts: 258
Joined: 2010-08-30 15:39

Re: No firemode indicator while zoomed

Post by MrTomRobs »

I'm going to have to agree with keeping it off the screen i'm afraid, for the simple fact that a good soldier always knows his weapon's condition. Whenever i've been on training, or done weapons handling tests, good practice has always been this (on an L85, which is another point i'll point out in a sec):

Magazine in -> SELECTOR LEVER TO R(epetition) -> Iron sights set to day-time aperture if they're used -> arm over and **** the weapon -> forward assist.

This is a simple drill that is etched into the skull of every bloke/blokette(?) in the british forces at least whenever they use an L85. They're also told not to change their selector lever unless told otherwise by squad/section leaders, which is usually when in FIBUA (Fighting In Built-Up Areas) or in CQB. the rest of the time, the selector lever is always at repetition.

Whilst i can only talk from my experiences, i'd imagine the same is true for american forces?

I've also got a little gripe with the two examples that have been used saying you can feel the selector lever. Yes, on the AR-15 you can feel it, because it is integral to the safety mechanism. Yes, on the AK series, you can see/feel where it is because it is integral to the safety mechanism.

On other weapons, especially the L85, the safety mechanism and the repetition mechanism are separated. Indeed, on the '85, the safety 'catch' is located right at the top of the hand guard, right next to the trigger guard, so the user can simply lift his finger and press if in if he wants his weapon on safe. The repetition selector is pretty much on the other end of the weapon, right next to the magazine housing. In order for him to feel or see where the selector lever is set to on this weapon, he would have to take his left hand off the weapon and try and feel for where it is (which means he's not in total control of his weapon, accuracy suffers etc etc), or he would have to physically look at it, which means he's not looking either down his sights so he can shoot at what he sees if necessary, or he's looking where he's going and Timmy, Tommy and Terry Taliban come around the corner and shove a bayonet through is face. Not pretty.

I think that having the fire-mode selector when you're not ADS, and not having it when you are is a good solution which gives the best of both worlds.
'There are 3 types of people in this world, those that can count, and those who can't.'

Image
Gwlad! Gwlad! Pleidiol wyf i'm Gwlad!
Joker86
Posts: 85
Joined: 2012-05-19 13:11

Re: No firemode indicator while zoomed

Post by Joker86 »

Not everyone is a trained soldier, and in reality your brain works differently and you have different focuses than while playing a game...
AfterDune
Retired PR Developer
Posts: 17094
Joined: 2007-02-08 07:19

Re: No firemode indicator while zoomed

Post by AfterDune »

The firemode indicator will be displayed in v1.0. It's a tiny A/1/3 in the bottom-right corner, should be fine.

As a soldier or whatever, you can still feel the switch so even if you don't know, you can check without having to actually look at it. Seeing the indicator on your screen will do that for you in-game.

That's all for now.
Image
KiloJules
Posts: 792
Joined: 2011-03-17 18:03

Re: No firemode indicator while zoomed

Post by KiloJules »

Good news.

As it seems v1.0 is gonna be da' shizz!
badmojo420
Posts: 2849
Joined: 2008-08-23 00:12

Re: No firemode indicator while zoomed

Post by badmojo420 »

I am happy to hear that.

Surprised there was a debate about all of this. Just the simple fact that your deviation/accuracy/etc changes when you unscope should be enough of a reason to add this.
Post Reply

Return to “Infantry”