ATGM on Armored Vehicles detonating off Tree branches

Post Reply
Imdruid
Posts: 21
Joined: 2010-01-07 02:31

ATGM on Armored Vehicles detonating off Tree branches

Post by Imdruid »

I don't know if this is a new thing, but i have never had it happen in previous patches. I have had several ATGMs detonate in the tree branches far from a collision box of the tree. I have not had a problem with this before hand. A tank can also fire AP and HE rounds through these branches but ATGMs do not travel through these branches. Is this part of a nerf to the ATGM? if so it is rather unrealistic and very detrimental to armored warfare. i have had this problem with both the Russian T-90A and the German PUMA. These ATGMs although fired in a way to avoid tree hit boxes seem to hit them either way. If you want i can get a video demonstrating. But to do so is not needed because it is easily reproducable


-sincerely someone who has played since patch .50
Before you ask, been playing since 2006 seen a lot of change, some good, most bad. :)
User avatar
Mineral
Retired PR Developer
Posts: 8534
Joined: 2012-01-02 12:37
Location: Belgium

Post by Mineral »

Given our tree Collision meshes didnt change this isn't anything new :)
Image
User avatar
Mats391
PR:BF2 Lead Developer
Posts: 7643
Joined: 2010-08-06 18:06

Re: ATGM on Armored Vehicles detonating off Tree branches

Post by Mats391 »

How is this unrealistic?
Wire guided: When firing through tree branches it is very likely that the wire gets entangled or snaps
Beam riding: No line of sight, no guiding
They might not explode right away, but certainly wont work reliable when shot through tree branches. Chances of it hitting a thicker branch and detonating is also there. AP and HEAT shells dont care about loss of guidance and will likely just punch through that bit of wood thanks to their kinetic energy.
Image

Mineral: TIL that Wire-guided missiles actually use wire
Barbrady
Posts: 121
Joined: 2013-04-03 12:07

Re: ATGM on Armored Vehicles detonating off Tree branches

Post by Barbrady »

Is there a system ingame simulating a wire on ATGM, for example steering it around an obstacle?
M42 Zwilling
Retired PR Developer
Posts: 613
Joined: 2012-06-10 11:27

Re: ATGM on Armored Vehicles detonating off Tree branches

Post by M42 Zwilling »

Not per se, though the guidance tends to get screwed if something gets between the target and the launcher. I've seen people firing an ATGM at a moving distant vehicle, and for a moment the crosshair passes over a close telephone pole. When this happens, the missile tries to figure out how to do a 180 turn and hit the telephone pole, and usually goes into the ground, to the confusion of the guiding player. I guess getting the wire wrapped around a telephone pole would produce a similar result.
Image


"How many posts have there been about how much better PR was back in 0.X? The fact is that if we played the older versions we would start to remember the shortcomings, but we tend to hold onto the good memories tighter than the bad ones." - Murphy
Post Reply

Return to “Vehicles”