Let us discuss - the suck that is M16

General discussion of the Project Reality: BF2 modification.
vanity
Posts: 562
Joined: 2007-02-08 12:57

Let us discuss - the suck that is M16

Post by vanity »

I admit, I used to be a fan of the M16. It was accurate and a good rifle in-game.

Then something happened. Maybe it's G3 scopes, I don't know, but this weapon is a major piece of ****. Here's why I think this:

1) Unless it's a head-shot, it takes 3-4 rounds to kill the enemy with the M16. That means Pop...Pop...Pop in single-shot at range. During that time, it takes 1 round from his G3 to kill you. More often than not, the enemy will get off 1 shot before you can kill him with your 3.

2) In burst mode, the M16 flies wildly up in the air and you must correct your aim with the mouse before firing again. With full-auto G3, the climb is consistent, so you can keep the rounds in one pattern while moving the mouse as you fire. That means the G3 can fire more rounds, more accurately, and of a higher caliber.

Maybe this is true to real life. I've never killed anyone with an M16 so I don't know. But I do know that if I had to shoot people 3 times square in the chest before they went down, I'd be picking up enemy weapons at every opportunity.
For PR I play exclusively on Tactical Gamer server as "vanity11"

For ArmA I play exclusively on Tactical Gamer (coop and evo) as "Vanity"
Cerberus
Posts: 2727
Joined: 2005-11-15 22:24

Post by Cerberus »

The burst mode is quite useless unless you're within a few meters of the enemy.
"Practice proves more than theory, in any case."

- Abraham Lincoln


"i so regret searching "giant hentai penis" on google images though ;_;"

- Garabaldi
Spartan452
Posts: 32
Joined: 2007-02-13 22:21

Post by Spartan452 »

Isn't that what people say about the M16's 5.56 round in real life, that you have to swiss cheese the guy and then some before he goes down?
Viper5
Posts: 3240
Joined: 2005-11-18 14:18

Post by Viper5 »

M16 IMO is the best service rifle in PR. Its accuracy is incredible. Although its recoil should be brought down a bit IMO... should have the least recoil of any rifle.
Last edited by Viper5 on 2007-07-31 17:29, edited 1 time in total.
GeZe
Retired PR Developer
Posts: 3450
Joined: 2006-02-09 22:09

Post by GeZe »

I think the M16 in game is accurately modeled. No need to change it.
bosco_
Retired PR Developer
Posts: 14620
Joined: 2006-12-17 19:04

Post by bosco_ »

'[R-PUB wrote:Viper5']M16 IMO is the best service rifle in PR. Its accuracy is incredible.
:|

@OP: I pick up a Type 95/G3 asap.
Image
Battlepudel
Posts: 235
Joined: 2007-05-24 21:40

Post by Battlepudel »

I actually like the zoom of the M16 better than any scope because i can see much more with it.

And i never use burst. But in small sideways it is a very good choice to smash your fire button to oblivion.
SiN|ScarFace
Posts: 5818
Joined: 2005-09-08 19:59

Post by SiN|ScarFace »

5.56 is notorious for not putting people down on the first shot center mass. In game it is lame to get the first hit as US only to get blown away by the other guy who is wounded.

I actually don't care about the difference btwn the effectiveness of the bullets. What I do care about and have been saying since .3 is that getting the first hit on the other guy should be the deciding factor in the fight. Things like blur have been added but that is SUPERFICIAL and does nothing to handicap the person who was shot in a realistic way.
If you take a round center mass while you are aiming your own rifle, there is no way your aim will NOT be negatively influenced off target. When you get struck it should totally throw your aim off the target and most likely you wouldn't be aiming at all at that time and reacting to being hit and NOT accurately returning fire.

Your vision should blur and aim thrown off somehow, Like if you get hit it would reset your weapon back to the hip position (out of iron sight) and you would have to bring your weapon to bear again, while still in blurred vision.

If this could be done, 5.56 vs 7.62 would be a non issue really.
Image
VipersGhost
Posts: 1171
Joined: 2007-03-27 18:34

Post by VipersGhost »

Yeah you guys are crazy if you think the M16 is better than the G3...no offense. I can put about the same number of rounds on a target in 10 secs with the scoped G3 as well as the scoped M16. Maybe the M16 is fine, but one of these guns needs to be changed...it's the G3 in my eyes. The G3 has 400% more recoil than the M16 (this isn't modeled correctly in PR), yet in-game the extra recoil on the G3 is quite negligible. I think the recoil model itself needs to change as well, sticky recoil? Maybe thats where the problem lies.
SiN|ScarFace
Posts: 5818
Joined: 2005-09-08 19:59

Post by SiN|ScarFace »

Recoil on an M16 (AR) type weapon is all but absorbed by the spring in the stock. Anyone who has fired one on single shot will know what I'm talking about.
Image
Revelation_Space
Posts: 47
Joined: 2007-07-27 20:39

Post by Revelation_Space »

I hear you man, I hate the M16 too, especially the major lack of zoom - though it's a lot better than the Insurgent and Militia weapons.

I'm getting to the stage now, where I don't even fire at an enemy holding a G3 at medium-long range if he's seen me, because he WILL win the fire-fight, no question. I just try and hide until he gets close.

Also, I leave the M16 on burst all the time. It's a lot easier to switch to semi to fire at a ranged target, than it is to quickly switch to burst when you're surprised by 2 guys walking around a corner.
vanity
Posts: 562
Joined: 2007-02-08 12:57

Post by vanity »

SiN|ScarFace wrote: Your vision should blur and aim thrown off somehow, Like if you get hit it would reset your weapon back to the hip position (out of iron sight) and you would have to bring your weapon to bear again, while still in blurred vision.

If this could be done, 5.56 vs 7.62 would be a non issue really.
I really like this idea. That major problem is not that my rifle doesn't kill on the first shot, it's that while I'm hammering someone with multiple rounds they're returning effective fire and killing me.

I'm shooting a guy in the chest 2-3 times and he's able to aim and kill me? No way. That's sounds to be the real problem, not the M16.
For PR I play exclusively on Tactical Gamer server as "vanity11"

For ArmA I play exclusively on Tactical Gamer (coop and evo) as "Vanity"
billdan
Posts: 319
Joined: 2007-04-13 22:58

Post by billdan »

i prefer the g3/type95/l85a2, but i still like the m16 quite a lot. the m16 has the highest rate of fire (though it's burst) and lowest recoil.
maybe the g3 recoil does need a boost

ACOG crosshairs will surely be an improvement over the thick arse m16 front sight post
|TG-69th|Mix0lydian in-game
Warne
Posts: 33
Joined: 2007-02-03 14:34

Post by Warne »

M16 would be far better with a scope to take advantage of it's accuracy. M16 has no power and no usefulness in burst, which means it's more effecient in single-fire, which just goes back to the fact that it has no power. I'll be glad for .7 when the M16 can be used more to it's advantages. I'm not sure what the purpose was of leaving the scope off the USMC weapon when every other organized military, even the cheap Chinese, got one. As is, USMC is at a major disadvantage, given even the usually invincible M1 Abrams is a pinata to less advanced tanks on the battlefield.

That's prolly the one gripe I have about .6. Unfair scope dispersal.
ReaperMAC
Posts: 3055
Joined: 2007-02-11 19:16

Post by ReaperMAC »

vanity wrote:I really like this idea. That major problem is not that my rifle doesn't kill on the first shot, it's that while I'm hammering someone with multiple rounds they're returning effective fire and killing me.

I'm shooting a guy in the chest 2-3 times and he's able to aim and kill me? No way. That's sounds to be the real problem, not the M16.
Exactly, it is always disheartening when you think you got the jump on some one but they turn around, prone and kill you in one-headshot :-(
Image
PR Test Team: [COLOR="Black"]Serious Business[/COLOR]
[R-DEV]dbzao: My head Rhino.... (long pause) My beautiful head
[R-DEV]Rhino - If you want to spam do it in the tester area please.
Control the Media, Control the Mind.
Woolfson
Posts: 82
Joined: 2007-02-09 09:23

Post by Woolfson »

1st big difference with M16 in PR I felt in ver.5 - become "more" lethal, from 0.5 till now (0.6) not such difference, maybe because G3 with scope is quite serious weapon nowadays...?
VipersGhost
Posts: 1171
Joined: 2007-03-27 18:34

Post by VipersGhost »

Lets not get into the scope thing guys. They couldn't get it in on time with .6 and thats why its not there. The G3 needs more recoil for sure...I've put a red dot on my screen(marker) when fighting with the M16 and it helps...but its not insanely better. The G3 is still very dominant due to the size, speed and accuracy of firing it. I think Scarface hit one of the prevailing issues here as well with bullet-hit having no effect on an opponents accuracy. So in essence, it's just a trading of bullets or a race for the headshot in firefights. This isn't realisitc and GREATLY favors the person with the larger round. In my mind the G3 is just an M16 with fewer rounds, full auto, same accuracy, slightly more recoil, and WAY more killing power. Where is the disadvantage in that? Where is the speed vs power here? Its like giving Ali all his abilities PLUS Fraziers power.

1-G3 recoil
2-No effect from being shot
TheAmazingYant
Posts: 269
Joined: 2007-07-07 06:53

Post by TheAmazingYant »

Although a scope isn't modeled, the M16 does have an effective "Zoom" on the kits that would normally be equipped with a scope, such as the rifleman kit. You get the benefits of a scope without the limited sight.
Guerra
Posts: 365
Joined: 2007-02-15 17:19

Post by Guerra »

5.56mm sucks. Long live the 7.62mm round.

I miss the old FN FALs...

So, when is PR going to get the Canadian Armed Forces, eh? Some nice C7A1 action.
GeZe
Retired PR Developer
Posts: 3450
Joined: 2006-02-09 22:09

Post by GeZe »

VipersGhost wrote:I've put a red dot on my screen(marker) when fighting with the M16 and it helps...but its not insanely better.
Umm what?
Locked

Return to “PR:BF2 General Discussion”