Fire in the hole! - Grenades down a tanks hatch

[Pure_beef]

I searched, can't find so here is what I would like to see. There has been a few occasions, infact alot of occasions where I have found my squad caught out by a tank, as no1 has an AT kit you are forced to hide for 5 mins until the tank rolls past. I dont mind doing this, however recently I have decided to try something new: Wait for tank to stop, jump up onto turret undetected and then see what I can do.

First few times I did this I decided to get a grenade and throw it down the OPEN hatch, result - grenade bounces back up at me and injures me (badly) tank realises what is happening and shoots me.

Im sure many of you have been in a situation where the only explosive you have is a grenade and you wish you had AT, as the tank comes closer towards your face. The nearest supply crate is 500m away and you are 100 m from the flag. What can you do apart from run and hide?

My suggestion is that if someone successfully gets onto the tanks roof, they can then throw a grenade down the hatch and kill all crew members inside, the grenade doesn't have to destroy the tank. Simply taking out the crew would do. I remember something similar with grenades in APC gun holes on BF:V or 1942?! It would be a great reward for any infantry able to do this, as well as a great performance to watch!
All the tank would have to do to avoid this, is never stop moving for more than a few seconds.

[Smegburt_funkledink]

So, give the tanks the option to open and close their hatches to aviod this.... Otherwise it would be silly that every tank crew could be taken out in such a way.

To do so, all of the tanks would need to be custom PR models and then the British Challenger 2 would have to be partly re-done.

[arjan]

Suggested before, this was only done in ww2 and verry dangerous.
So not realistic.

[DannyIMK]

maybe also hardcoded?

and what about the gunner(the machinegun not cannon gunner) he can stop you from throwing the grenade

[Tirak]

In real life, in a combat zone, tanks would button up, creating a lack of said open hatch to throw your grenade into. Since the BF2 engine cannot handle buttoning up and unbuttoning in a way that the .50 cal gunner on the roof takes cover inside the tank, this will never happen. In any event:

Resuggestion,

Please use the Search Function and the *** List before posting suggestions.

[supahpingi]

maybe also hardcoded?

and what about the gunner(the machinegun not cannon gunner) he can stop you from throwing the grenade

You can throw a nade into a humvee or in the back of a truck,so that should be possible,the opening of hatches is possible think like bf42 higgins(with arrow keys)

But it is prolly hardcoded for a players to actually manage to get upon a tank during combat and throw a nade inside(and anyone with more then 1 braincell would close the hatch anyway)

[Outlawz7]

Remodel us all tanks in PR with an actual interior inside them and maybe it will be possible. But for now I doubt throwing a grenade into a hatch which has a mesh ending at 40cm depth is rather possible.

[Bob_Marley]

Resuggestion & unpossible with current tank models.

Locked.