The Chinook

General discussion of the Project Reality: BF2 modification.
Locked
Rhino
Retired PR Developer
Posts: 47909
Joined: 2005-12-13 20:00

Re: The Chinook

Post by Rhino »

Sgt.Smeg wrote: :shock: < My face after first flight in the Lynx.
And dont forget about the passengers!

https://www.realitymod.com/forum/f10-pr ... -army.html
Image
Cassius
Posts: 3958
Joined: 2008-04-14 17:37

Re: The Chinook

Post by Cassius »

'[R-DEV wrote:Rhino;909284']ehhh no, I was with the Chinook idea if I wasn't it would have not been made :p

The CH-46 Sea Knight is a entirely different story how ever that I've explained many times before thou I'll give it a go again.

As many of you are probably aware, the CH-46 Sea Knight is in the processes of being Phased out of the USMC / US Navy and being replaced by the new V-22, ie, it dose not have much life left in it in the real world. PR is always wanting to crate the most upto date hardware with focusing PR a few years ahead of the real time and there is no point making something that is no longer in service. One example of this many of you may remember the British Saxon that was in v0.4 and a bit in v0.5, ie this thing for thous of you who dont: Project Reality Mod for Battlefield 2 AT105 Saxon - Render image - Mod DB

Soon after finishing it we found our from one of our MAs that the British Army no longer used this and it was being phased out, only place is it still currently used in the British Armed forces today is in the TA, hence why you do not see it ingame as its unrealistic. That and its not upto par with the rest of our models.

Now the next main issue is this, even if we made a CH-46, we have no real maps to use it on. Really you need a 4km map to even think about using a chopper like this on, anything under is really too small with possibly a few minor acceptions to the rule, but all the current USMC maps that are fit for any kind of chopper, Muttrah, Jabal, op barra and qwai river all would not fit one on it. And yes I did not mention Op Archer as that is going to become a Canadian Forces map in the future like it was planned from the start but even that wouldn't fit one on well. There is also no future maps that are currently in development by the team that could use it. Where as the CH-47 Chinook on the other hand has 3 maps, 2 current and one upcoming that could use it (Sangin being the main one, but also Qinling and Kashan could easily use it in there infantry only layers).

So to go though why each map wouldn't work with them:
Muttrah: not enough LZs for a large chopper, map dose fine with the current choppers and transport choppers become less useful the deeper the team get into the city and too small.
Jabal: too small.
Op Barra: not enough LZs for such a chopper and too small.
Qwia River: to small view distance for a black hawk let alone a Sea Knight.

Now onto my final point, I mentioned before the Ch-46 Sea Knight was being replaced by the V-22 in the future. Well as it happens PR has a V-22 model from the RC mod that gave it to us when they shut down. I can not say it is the best model etc ever but its ingame and it works. All it would need for it to be used in PR is really a bunch of coding tweaks etc, so your probably asking now, why do PR not use this? Well the answer to that is simple as its the last one, no maps for it, and where size is a issue for the CH-46 size is a even bigger issue for the V-22 because it has a much higher top speed and it is much bigger meaning LZs are much harder to come by. I mean, its a struggle to land it on the roof of one of thous huge T apartment buildings.

Image

now that shot is from a REALLY big WIP of muttrah where I was looking at the possibility, that was in the 17th of September 2007 according to the dates on the image.

So to recap on it I will list the points as to why we will never make a CH-46 Sea Knight.
  • Being retired so would not be a realistic asset ingame see as PR is for the most part set a few years in the future
  • No current or upcoming maps would even fit it
  • If we did have maps for it, we have a V-22 already made for the job
Hope that explains that...
Hopefully it will serve well. So far all it did was kill Americans. Seriously more people died getting this thing in the air than Americans on the moon, but cudos to them for not asking zhe Germans to fix it halfway through :p .
I wonder what everybody things of the offsprey, its gonna be "in game" irl, but dont you think it looks to spacey to fit in the army or Marines ?
|TG|cap_Kilgore
Image
jbgeezer
Posts: 908
Joined: 2008-06-10 15:30

Re: The Chinook

Post by jbgeezer »

Ahh chinook, whats the point?
Live by the sword, die by the sword...

Ingame:G-LockCobra
http://www.youtube.com/user/sotemot
Incomplete Spork
Posts: 436
Joined: 2008-12-30 03:26

Re: The Chinook

Post by Incomplete Spork »

To be 1337
Image
Jigsaw
Posts: 4498
Joined: 2008-09-15 02:31

Re: The Chinook

Post by Jigsaw »

hiberNative wrote:i would have enjoyed seeing the chinook in the sky more than the lynx, but the lynx will probably be more effective ;P
Wait till you fly it. OMG says it all :D

Plus a big part of Rhino's post that he made very clear was that there simply were more maps at the present time where the Lynx could be used than there are for the chinook.

Chinook can wait until maps like Feyzebad and Sangin are complete :D
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8CKjNcSUNt8
"I love the smell of napalm in the morning. You know, one time we had a hill bombed, for 12 hours. When it was all over, I walked up. We didn't find one of 'em, not one stinkin' dink body. The smell, you know that gasoline smell, the whole hill. Smelled like... victory. Someday this war's gonna end... "
ReaperAce712
Posts: 135
Joined: 2008-06-08 16:56

Re: The Chinook

Post by ReaperAce712 »

[quote=""'[R-DEV"]Rhino;909284'] Now the next main issue is this, even if we made a CH-46, we have no real maps to use it on[/quote]
Thats all I wanted to know


[quote="Cassius""] I wonder what everybody things of the offsprey, its gonna be "in game" irl, but dont you think it looks to spacey to fit in the army or Marines ?[/quote]

And its Osprey not Offsprey, and it is quite roomy I have seen one up and close and it can fit quite a large load in the back. If im not mistaken it can carry around 20 - 25 men in the back or a load of 1000lbs.
Last edited by ReaperAce712 on 2009-01-22 13:21, edited 2 times in total.
Image
"Cluster bombing from B-52s is very, very accurate.
The bombs are guaranteed to always hit the ground."
-U.S. Air Force
Glimmerman
Retired PR Developer
Posts: 3237
Joined: 2007-08-14 11:12

Re: The Chinook

Post by Glimmerman »

PFunk wrote:Didn't Canada sell those to you guys in the 90s?
Yes we bought some refurbished Chinooks from Canada that we have upgraded since then and some new ones from Boeing.
Tannhauser
Posts: 1210
Joined: 2007-11-22 03:06

Re: The Chinook

Post by Tannhauser »

[R-DEV]Rhino wrote:We will surely use it on more than one map, even when its released for example I can see the Chinook fitting pretty well on Qinling Infantry layer where transport choppers are a key role on it, As well as it fitting on Kashan and future US Army and other faction maps. We also have EoD2 and many other BSS Mods exspressing there intreast in the Chinook, which we plan to allow them to use it after all the help they have given us, with exporting the Lynx and will be exporting the Chinook etc.

Again, think of the Chinook as a flying truck, where its biggest role is logistics as well as transport. that has the proportional of setting up a firebase on a LZ that will spawn off many more players than just 8.
Will it be possible to make reskins of the Chinook for those community factions that will need it if they ever make a map that can handle one?
«Hollywood jackasses who insist on spending seriously huge amounts of money to make films that even my cat won't watch. And he'll happily sit in the bathroom and watch me shit.»
- [R-DEV]Masaq
Mitsotribal
Posts: 7
Joined: 2008-12-31 18:39

Re: The Chinook

Post by Mitsotribal »

Chinooks do paradrops and fast roping...Will paradrops be added in PR?...Chinooks are very well known and suitable for paradrops...

Paratroopers !
nick20404
Posts: 1746
Joined: 2007-06-30 23:36

Re: The Chinook

Post by nick20404 »

Correct me if I am wrong but didn't the brits only send 6 or 7 Chinooks in total to Afghanistan? They should cost more tickets or take a really long time to respawn.
charliegrs
Posts: 2027
Joined: 2007-01-17 02:19

Re: The Chinook

Post by charliegrs »

Tannhauser wrote:Will it be possible to make reskins of the Chinook for those community factions that will need it if they ever make a map that can handle one?
hopefully they will do a re-skin for the US army
known in-game as BOOMSNAPP
'
Koroush47
Posts: 268
Joined: 2009-02-16 15:00

Re: The Chinook

Post by Koroush47 »

charliegrs wrote:hopefully they will do a re-skin for the US army
Makes sense, seeing as the US owns the most Chinooks in the world. :evil:
PFunk
Posts: 1072
Joined: 2008-03-31 00:09

Re: The Chinook

Post by PFunk »

And for when the Canadian Forces get theirs airborne.

Edit. Actually.

Image
http://www.army.forces.gc.ca/lf/english/6_1_1.asp?id=3331
Last edited by PFunk on 2009-03-27 04:39, edited 1 time in total.
[PR]NATO|P*Funk
Image
Image
Qaiex
Posts: 7279
Joined: 2009-02-28 21:05

Re: The Chinook

Post by Qaiex »

And then it just needs a few alterations and bam, it turns into a CH-46 Sea Knight for the Marines.
charliegrs
Posts: 2027
Joined: 2007-01-17 02:19

Re: The Chinook

Post by charliegrs »

qaiex wrote:And then it just needs a few alterations and bam, it turns into a CH-46 Sea Knight for the Marines.
i dont know how many people have said this exact same thing, but its totally wrong.

the sea knight is not just a mini chinook. theres quite a few differences.
known in-game as BOOMSNAPP
'
Rhino
Retired PR Developer
Posts: 47909
Joined: 2005-12-13 20:00

Re: The Chinook

Post by Rhino »

charliegrs wrote:the sea knight is not just a mini chinook. theres quite a few differences.
let me correct that a sec, there's quite a few MAJOR differences...

besides a Sea Knight will NEVER be made for PR as its being phased out of service and replaced by the v22 which we already have in PR courtesy of the old RC mod but we just dont have any map for it....

I dunno how many times I have to say this...

EDIT: oh dear god I in fact said it a few pages back in this topic....

[quote=""'[R-DEV"]Rhino;909284']ehhh no, I was with the Chinook idea if I wasn't it would have not been made :p

The CH-46 Sea Knight is a entirely different story how ever that I've explained many times before thou I'll give it a go again.

As many of you are probably aware, the CH-46 Sea Knight is in the processes of being Phased out of the USMC / US Navy and being replaced by the new V-22, ie, it dose not have much life left in it in the real world. PR is always wanting to crate the most upto date hardware with focusing PR a few years ahead of the real time and there is no point making something that is no longer in service. One example of this many of you may remember the British Saxon that was in v0.4 and a bit in v0.5, ie this thing for thous of you who dont: Project Reality Mod for Battlefield 2 AT105 Saxon - Render image - Mod DB

Soon after finishing it we found our from one of our MAs that the British Army no longer used this and it was being phased out, only place is it still currently used in the British Armed forces today is in the TA, hence why you do not see it ingame as its unrealistic. That and its not upto par with the rest of our models.

Now the next main issue is this, even if we made a CH-46, we have no real maps to use it on. Really you need a 4km map to even think about using a chopper like this on, anything under is really too small with possibly a few minor acceptions to the rule, but all the current USMC maps that are fit for any kind of chopper, Muttrah, Jabal, op barra and qwai river all would not fit one on it. And yes I did not mention Op Archer as that is going to become a Canadian Forces map in the future like it was planned from the start but even that wouldn't fit one on well. There is also no future maps that are currently in development by the team that could use it. Where as the CH-47 Chinook on the other hand has 3 maps, 2 current and one upcoming that could use it (Sangin being the main one, but also Qinling and Kashan could easily use it in there infantry only layers).

So to go though why each map wouldn't work with them:
Muttrah: not enough LZs for a large chopper, map dose fine with the current choppers and transport choppers become less useful the deeper the team get into the city and too small.
Jabal: too small.
Op Barra: not enough LZs for such a chopper and too small.
Qwia River: to small view distance for a black hawk let alone a Sea Knight.

Now onto my final point, I mentioned before the Ch-46 Sea Knight was being replaced by the V-22 in the future. Well as it happens PR has a V-22 model from the RC mod that gave it to us when they shut down. I can not say it is the best model etc ever but its ingame and it works. All it would need for it to be used in PR is really a bunch of coding tweaks etc, so your probably asking now, why do PR not use this? Well the answer to that is simple as its the last one, no maps for it, and where size is a issue for the CH-46 size is a even bigger issue for the V-22 because it has a much higher top speed and it is much bigger meaning LZs are much harder to come by. I mean, its a struggle to land it on the roof of one of thous huge T apartment buildings.

Image

now that shot is from a REALLY big WIP of muttrah where I was looking at the possibility, that was in the 17th of September 2007 according to the dates on the image.

So to recap on it I will list the points as to why we will never make a CH-46 Sea Knight.
  • Being retired so would not be a realistic asset ingame see as PR is for the most part set a few years in the future
  • No current or upcoming maps would even fit it
  • If we did have maps for it, we have a V-22 already made for the job
Hope that explains that...[/quote]



[quote="Mitsotribal""]Chinooks do paradrops and fast roping...Will paradrops be added in PR?...Chinooks are very well known and suitable for paradrops...

Paratroopers ![/quote]

some one please kill me! I can't take much more of this :(

nick20404 wrote:Correct me if I am wrong but didn't the brits only send 6 or 7 Chinooks in total to Afghanistan? They should cost more tickets or take a really long time to respawn.
I'm pretty sure that there is more than 6 or 7 in Afghanistan right now, not sure on how many.

Tannhauser wrote:Will it be possible to make reskins of the Chinook for those community factions that will need it if they ever make a map that can handle one?
yes, just like the Apache...
Last edited by Rhino on 2009-03-27 06:15, edited 1 time in total.
Image
General_J0k3r
Posts: 2051
Joined: 2007-03-02 16:01

Re: The Chinook

Post by General_J0k3r »

if you're not careful rhino will have a heart attack and then you won't get shit ;)
Glimmerman
Retired PR Developer
Posts: 3237
Joined: 2007-08-14 11:12

Re: The Chinook

Post by Glimmerman »

If he gets a hart attack and the chinook fails we all have a hart attack so leave the man alone wil ya! ;)
Mad-Mike
Posts: 3137
Joined: 2008-01-25 13:21

Re: The Chinook

Post by Mad-Mike »

im looking forward for this, im being very patient lol :-D
it will be good to fly or be transported in, especialy when its flew over my head alot and been inside and on it
Alex6714
Posts: 3900
Joined: 2007-06-15 22:47

Re: The Chinook

Post by Alex6714 »

Image
"Today's forecast calls for 30mm HE rain with a slight chance of hellfires"


"oh, they're fire and forget all right...they're fired then they forget where the target is"
Locked

Return to “PR:BF2 General Discussion”