Project Reality Forums

I don't really see that problem, what else is the coloured smoke nade for anyway other then signalling? Just needs to go alot higher and take less time to deploy, no need for it to spread out either obviously. The green smoke is useless, and I only ever see it get used when an officer runs out of grey smoke and all it does is the same thing but screams "kill me first" at the enemy.

I use them occasionally for signalling but just for a laugh when my squad will be easily seen anyway, not when I actually need spotting cos they're ****ing useless for that purpose at the moment.

AnRK wrote:I don't really see that problem, what else is the coloured smoke nade for anyway other then signalling? Just needs to go alot higher and take less time to deploy, no need for it to spread out either obviously. The green smoke is useless, and I only ever see it get used when an officer runs out of grey smoke and all it does is the same thing but screams "kill me first" at the enemy.

I use them occasionally for signalling but just for a laugh when my squad will be easily seen anyway, not when I actually need spotting cos they're ****ing useless for that purpose at the moment.

Yeah, I hate putting a sign on my back saying kill me!!!!

A flare would just say hello! and then its gone, yes they know your in that direction but you wont have a big green smoke blob saying RIGHT HERE!!!!!!!

hmm, for the slot, i guess you could replace one of the two smokes that the squad leader has.

i think that it would be nice to have a flare that reacts differently than the smokes. instead of a cloud, its a steady stream of smoke going straight up.

would also be nice if this showed up as a laze, or as the kind of thing that a friendly aircraft has when you look at it with the AA (the circle with the x inside that you can't look onto)
might be an effective way to mark friendly troops on the field when you need CAS very close to your own position.

just ask all SLs in the area to pop flares and the air support can avoid friendly fire.

cplgangster wrote:also what if the pilot for what ever reason happens to miss the flare because they are looking the wrong way or are just out of range to see it properly. At least with the smoke it does stay there for a while and it can go if you get the chopper close enough to it it kinda disperses a bit.

You can possible make it hang in the air.

Like flares now. just like a heli flare. just shoot straight up and itll go down slowlyz



Itll be very usefull for crate dropping in muttrah. you can drop a crate from rooftop height and have it survive the fall.

mat552 wrote:I would much rather have the signal smoke that the officers used to have. It went in a cone upwards, rather than a huge plume in all directions.

Thats how signal smoke should be.

Instead of throwing a smoke, I order someone to put down a trip flare and use that instead.
It doesn't have the vibrant colours of the smoke, and it shoots a small smoke trail into the sky, letting helicopters see where I want the supply boxes to be dropped.

ahh yeh deffo good idea

something like that seen them from local army base while on beach one night had about 20 like these i would deffo prefer than a smoke

or they could put it in grenidier kit like the m32 grenade launcher has ir flares should be able to have normal flares

i like the idea would be awesome during a night map... but since we dont have that yet idk if its really worth a weapon slot

You can get the same effect on the ground with the incendiaries..

Put it on a M203 slot

what about ones like the ones used in transformers 2 i know its a film but its hard to find good examples

Cool idea, but if you request a chopper and you don't have 5-10 seconds to let the smoke appear and you want it to be replaced with a flare which will only appear for like 1 second is useless. Just my opinion if you have a chopper coming near you and you pop a flare he will probably wont have enough time to slow down and land he probably will have to turn around but that depends on how far the chopper is and when you pop the flare.

I say just keep the 2 smoke =\

I think it could be useful in night maps if there is gonna be any of em.

signal flares are an awesome idea because farrr too often you need an instant method of conveying a position of friendlies/enemies to other units (be they armoured or air...)

The major problem with smoke is the fact it takes a frigging long time to build up AND most importantly, if you release a smoke before an air vehicle is within view distance then the smoke will not draw for the pilot of said vehicle.
Release the smoke whilest the air support is within view distance and by the time its built up enough to be visible your air support has flown to china.

Imo a parachute flare would be best so it'll float for a while and be of use but anyway in short +1 for this idea

'[R-COM wrote:Sadist_Cain;1111709']signal flares are an awesome idea because farrr too often you need an instant method of conveying a position of friendlies/enemies to other units (be they armoured or air...)

Imo a parachute flare would be best so it'll float for a while and be of use but anyway in short +1 for this idea

Well, in lieu of it being implemented... you can always use a rifleman specialist in the squad, have him deploy a flare near the SL, then trip it when the pilot is in view.

Overall, I think it's a good idea, just not sure how well it would work with some of the already limited equipment (maybe take out 'signal' smoke and replace it? take away officer's incendiary?)... putting it in without taking out something that is useful in it's own right seems like unlikely.

Would be good, except it would be hard to use for airstrikes..

I'm assuming you mean a flaregun, not a trip flare.. btw.


I would love to see a flaregun in PR :3

we could make it a flare gun like in the orriginal BLOOD games. You can shot it at people too and it sticks to them

It would be cool but it would probaly take too much time...

the best scenario for flares would be if only the commander was able to see the green dots on the map, everyone else just has a blank open space.

remember that SLs can have Reinforcements, APC AND Helicopter markers at their whim so the map would hardly be useless.

It'd be sweet for the flare to be engineered in as part of a bigger picture in order to be genuinly useful and not just a toy. Choppers still have a marker on map, but a flare to guide into a good LZ would be nice too... ideally...