shotguns in the .6 beta are fixed?

General discussion of the Project Reality: BF2 modification.
Post Reply
SethLive!
Posts: 1582
Joined: 2007-02-10 22:46

shotguns in the .6 beta are fixed?

Post by SethLive! »

Are the .6 beta shotguns the "fixed" ones? the buckshot still has an unrealisticly huge spread. the slug is fine, but man, is that buckshot inaccurate. its effective range is about 25 meters tops. shouldnt it be effective out to 50 or more meters?
Image
Someone please tell me that the above is irony.
Or I'll rip my own eyes out with a sardine.
-[R-Mod] Masaq
El_Vikingo
Posts: 4877
Joined: 2006-11-27 01:50

Post by El_Vikingo »

SethLive! wrote:Are the .6 beta shotguns the "fixed" ones? the buckshot still has an unrealisticly huge spread. the slug is fine, but man, is that buckshot inaccurate. its effective range is about 25 meters tops. shouldnt it be effective out to 50 or more meters?
Well....I usually go for a flock of birds when I shoot, that way I get atleast one hit. My favourite are seagulls.
Image

If you are reading this dont stop, cause if you do, I'll kick you in the balls.
ZaZZo
Posts: 1494
Joined: 2007-02-03 18:37

Post by ZaZZo »

Aye those annoying seagulls...
Maybe shoot at a flock of Brits when using buckshots?
danthemanbuddy
Posts: 842
Joined: 2006-11-12 19:07

Post by danthemanbuddy »

Yeah, I think the buckshot should be more realistic. Effective to 60m and the spread should not be as ridiculously wide as it is.
robbo
Posts: 1159
Joined: 2006-10-25 15:14

Post by robbo »

All depends on the type of shell used barrel length, but yeh i agree the buckshot spread is like a sawn off shotgun.
Desertfox
Posts: 5886
Joined: 2006-08-15 06:41

Post by Desertfox »

'[R-DEV wrote:xW0LFx']hell yea i got quoted :)
Share the joy! Quote me =D
Image
BirdShot
Posts: 83
Joined: 2006-03-03 16:43

Post by BirdShot »

60 Meters?

Jesus, what kind of load are you using? I'm lucky to get 50 yards in a tight pattern with an 870.
BUCKSHOT; The industry standard for the spread pattern of a 12ga shotgun is 1" per yard. So taking this into account the shot pattern at 15yds would be 15", 20yds would be 20" and so on. The average width of a human torso squared toward the shooter is 18"; this target area drops down to 12" if the target turns at an angle. This patterning formula has been proven time and time again using standard police shotguns. With this data we can assume that the maximum effective range on a man size target with the 12ga buckshot is 18yds. This is seven yards shorter than our officers qualify with their handguns. If the target turns the maximum effective range drops down to 12 yds. It is also common for officers to be aware of the pattern or spread on a shotgun and they will often sacrifice accuracy out of belief that some of the shot will hit the target.
From here:
http://www.blackwaterusa.com/btw2004/ar ... 22epp.html


BS
Lampshade111
Posts: 401
Joined: 2007-06-08 19:37

Post by Lampshade111 »

I think 60 meters is pushing it. The spread is so bad now I would be happy just to see a good grouping at 30 meters.
Deadmonkiefart
Posts: 632
Joined: 2007-02-06 04:33

Post by Deadmonkiefart »

My #1 excuse for having a bad game:
"GET-OFF-OF-MY-KEYBOARD-YOU-STUPID-CAT!!!"
Image
bezoar
Posts: 31
Joined: 2006-09-17 22:05

Post by bezoar »

sorry, but no one is going to hit ANYTHING with a shotgun at 60 meters with damage to put you down.
"your mom goes to college!"
Deadmonkiefart
Posts: 632
Joined: 2007-02-06 04:33

Post by Deadmonkiefart »

bezoar wrote:sorry, but no one is going to hit ANYTHING with a shotgun at 60 meters with damage to put you down.
Of coure not, but they should be able to kill in one shot out to 35 meters at least. Right now they don't even do well at 15 meters.
My #1 excuse for having a bad game:
"GET-OFF-OF-MY-KEYBOARD-YOU-STUPID-CAT!!!"
Image
VipersGhost
Posts: 1171
Joined: 2007-03-27 18:34

Post by VipersGhost »

I'm pretty sure they are being fixed in the next build. Lets hope so at least, its disappointing having all these cool guns and the shotgun being so lamo. It'd be a real blast to be able move through thealleyways bucking people with the shotty :)

"I'll swollow your soul, I'll swollow your soul!!!" - demon witch

"Swollow this *****!!" BOOM *shotgun* - Bruce Cambell
Thunder
Posts: 2061
Joined: 2006-05-30 17:56

Post by Thunder »

'[R-DEV wrote:xW0LFx']you *******, now he dosen't have my quote anymore :evil:
quick some one sig that quote.

i like the shot guns and have no problem with them.
but i see two problems with the tweaking.
1) it doesn't fire a tone of BB, bit rather something like 6-12 projectiles IIRC

2) if it would have a extended range to something like 60m people would still complain its either too weak or too powerfull.

i loved it in .5 for killing medics and spec ops as you could kill a unarmored guy with one hit, the problem is now all classes exept spec ops now ware body armor.

i would add more but i got to zip off to work.
Image
Long Bow
Posts: 1100
Joined: 2007-03-21 14:41

Post by Long Bow »

VipersGhost wrote:
"I'll swollow your soul, I'll swollow your soul!!!" - demon witch

"Swollow this *****!!" BOOM *shotgun* - Bruce Cambell

QFT :wink: Best one liner movies of all time

I have played ghost train in 0.5 and wiped out whole squads with the shotgun (you underestimate the level of my sneakeniss - Mr. Deeds). But on Basrah when you engage people at 50yds your done. I think people are expecting to much out of 00 bucksot. The slugs should be sledge-hammers out to 100yds though I don't think they penetrate body armour very well. Still it would do some internal damage from the impact energy :grin:
VipersGhost
Posts: 1171
Joined: 2007-03-27 18:34

Post by VipersGhost »

I think the shotty should be 1-shot kill at 15 meters(maybe 20) and 35 if you have no body armor...even if you have body armor your extremeties will be grosly disabled after being whacked at such close range with 00 buckshot ( BIG LOAD). The issue is not the load being fired...its the REDICULOUSLY fake spread. These are full-choked *** kicking machines within 35 meters...with 50m's still doing some damage. No nerfing...I'm not saying it doesn't work now or anything, thats not the point. Its that the gun doesn't handle anything like its RL counter-part and that is the ultimate goal.
jackal22
Posts: 849
Joined: 2006-11-18 20:18

Post by jackal22 »

on another note, i though shotties were fased out of most european armies and something to do with geneva convention saying they were in-humane but it was a grey area and some units in us still use them

thats what i remember, i dont know if its true or not but i read it some where i mean it makes semi sense, when was the last time you saw some one going into combat with a shotty that wasnt a specific close quaters or anti terrorism job?
Image
VipersGhost
Posts: 1171
Joined: 2007-03-27 18:34

Post by VipersGhost »

Yeah I agree, but they are more and more common within the urban environment fighting in Iraq...usually for house clearing\breaching.
lonelyjew
Posts: 3176
Joined: 2005-12-19 03:39

Post by lonelyjew »

robbo wrote:All depends on the type of shell used barrel length, but yeh i agree the buckshot spread is like a sawn off shotgun.
Actually, the choke is what makes all the differences.

Anyways, I think birdshot already answered the question. Buckshot just isn't too accurate, it's not meant to be accurate. Slugs on the other hand can reach out pretty far, especially with a rifled barrel though I don't imagine you would change your barrel out in combat too often.
Thanks luizinhuu for the find
Image

People are hopelessly ignorant of their own ignorance.
-Me
Post Reply

Return to “PR:BF2 General Discussion”